Monday, January 15, 2018

Proof For Our Approach To Understanding Revelation, Part 1

In our study of Revelation we have made two important points that guide our interpretation of the entire book: (1) It is highly symbolic in the manner in which it conveys truth. (2) It is a tightly-structured book from beginning to end, one whose visions in chapters six through twenty recapitulate what is taking place from the first coming to the second coming of Jesus Christ. In that recapitulation, each cycle also progresses beyond the previous ones in conveying the full picture of what is happening in this present age, as well as how God is applying his salvation to his people and taking care of them.

In this post and the next I want to provide proof for these two points, especially since they lead us away from the way the book has been most popularly understood for the past century or so.

In this post we will look at proof for the first point. 

1. Proof For The Symbolic Nature Of The Book.

a. Proof Of Symbolism In General.

There are several proofs we offer here. 

(1) As we have already seen, Revelation 1:1 tells us that God “signified” (or symbolized) the truth in the book. We need not spend more time on this verse. Simply-put, because of what we are told here, we should expect a good deal of symbolism.

(2) In addition to being a prophetic letter, the genre that comprises the book is what scholars call apocalyptic literature. There are other examples in Scripture (in Isaiah, Daniel, and Zechariah, especially) and also in books outside of Scripture between the testaments and in the first century A.D. These works, with a great amount of symbolism, tend to “pull back the curtains” on what is happening in history to reveal other-worldly visions of what is taking place as God defeats his enemies, takes care of his people, and applies the work of salvation and the work of judgment throughout history and into the age to come. None of these works are meant to give to us merely chronological depictions of what takes place either in history, at the end of history, or in the age-to-come.

(3) “The teaching of Balaam” is used in 2:14 to refer to false teaching that threatens to lead astray the church in Pergamum, most likely for material gain. It is highly doubtful that false teachers were literally going back to the literal teaching of the diviner whose story is told in Numbers 22-24, but that the errors of the false teachers in Pergamum resembled the errors of Balaam.

(4) Likewise, in 2:20f. the label “Jezebel” for a false teacher in Thyatira most likely is not intended to suggest her name literally was Jezebel, but that she was very much like the infamous and idolatrous Jezebel, wife of King Ahab, whose story is told in 1 Kings 16-2 Kings 9. 

(5) The “soiled garments” in Sardis (3:4), in the immediate context and the far context of Revelation, would speak of unrighteous actions that are unfaithful to and disobedient to God. The “white garments” of 3:5 would be just the opposite. Both speak of important truths, but both are symbolic, not literal references.

(6) In 3:15-16 the church in Laodicea is told its testimony and mission have been so compromised, they are good for nothing. The way this is communicated is by referring to two water sources in the area that were well known. There was cold water that came by aqueduct that was useful for drinking and there were also hot springs utilized for medicinal purposes. That they were neither hot nor cold created a picture, then, of them being useless for service to God in the same way the cold water mixed with the hot would be no good—either for drinking or medicinal purposes. It would be good for nothing. 

(7) The vision of the locusts in 9:3ff., which in context, are clearly demons, appear to be built upon both the book of Joel and the Exodus plagues before that in the Old Testament. The intent does not appear to be that we can expect such beings in the future (that is not how apocalyptic works). Nor is it intended to be understood in light of some kind of modern or future helicopter or the like. They are symbolic and to be interpreted by context and their Old Testament background. 

(8) In chapter 12 “woman” (referring to the people of God ), “dragon,” and “serpent” (referencing Satan) are all figurative—to be understood in light of their Old Testament background and the rest of the book of Revelation, but clearly not literal references. 

(9) In chapter 20 the text speaks of chains being used on spiritual beings who are placed in a “prison” or abyss. How would such physical entities hold a spiritual being?  Most likely these are symbolic reference. 

(10) “Babylon” (14:8; 16:19; 17:5; 18:1, 2, 10, 21) and “Euphrates” (9:14; 16:12) are used figuratively and with universal implications—speaking of the kingdom (even a city at one point, like in Is. 25:3: 16:19) that opposes God. These are clearly symbolic.

(11) In Revelation 21 we are told that the wall around the new Jerusalem is 216 feet thick (and most likely intended that is also its height [v. 17]). However, the city itself is just under 1,400 miles high (v. 16). What is more, the gates on the wall are never shut (v. 25). So, when we put all these together, the most likely conclusion is that the visions convey symbolic and yet very real truths, but are not intended to be taken literally. 

(12) Interestingly enough, there are many bits of evidence in in Revelation 21 that the temple pictured in the new heaven and new earth is the ultimate fulfillment of the end-times temple Ezekiel envisions in Ezekiel 40-48 and it is clearly not a physical or literal temple (see 21:22). If this is correct, not only do we see symbolism here in Revelation 21, but it also leads us to see Ezekiel 40-48 as intended symbolically. 

(13) There are many other proofs for the presence of symbolism we could offer (in fact we could take them from every page of Revelation, if not most paragraphs), but the point is sufficiently made. When we say that Revelation is “highly symbolic,” this is not merely an interpretation that we must follow in order to achieve our desired understanding. No, it is taken from the text itself and from the knowledge of other literature like Revelation. 

b. Proof Of The Symbolic Use Of Numbers.
Not only do we find symbolism in general, but also the symbolic use of numbers in the book, which would fit with all that we have seen about the expectation of symbolism.

(1) There are several uses of “seven” in the first chapter, a number that symbolically depicts perfection or fullness: “seven spirits (1:4)…seven stars( 1:16)…seven golden lampstands…the seven stars are the angels of the seven churches, and the seven lampstands are the seven churches” (1:20).

(2) The use of “ten days” in 2:10, to speak of a time of tribulation, is most likely drawn from the book of Daniel—as one of the many times in the book of Revelation in which we see what Daniel looked forward to in the far future is now being fulfilled—and yet it is not necessarily to be taken as literally 10 days. The point seems to be that God will take care of the believers in Smyrna as he did Daniel and his friends when they were tested for ten days (Dan. 1:12, 14, 15). 

(3) The Twenty-four elders of 4:4 (12 x 2), as well as the twelve patriarchal/tribal names on the New Jerusalem gates (21:12) and the twelve apostle names on the wall foundations of the new city (cf. 21:14) all depict the presence of the full people of God (Old and New Covenants [12 x 2]). 

(4) As we have already seen in the previous two weeks of study, the seven spirits and seven lamps of 4:5 are symbolic—referring to the Holy Spirit, through the eyes of the Zechariah 4 vision. 

(5) In 7:1-8 careful observation of the 144,000 redeemed in heaven (esp. as we look at the use of the tribes, the perfect numeration of 12,000 of each, the 12 x 12,000, and the parallelism between it and “a great multitude that no one could number” in 7:9) shows we almost certainly have a figurative or symbolic use of numbers in this text. It represents the full number of the people of God. 

(6) Of course the book structure of seven seals…seven trumpets, seven histories…seven plagues/bowls…all speak of both symbolism and a very tight structure for the book.

(7)  In Rev. 10:6 the clause “that there would be no more delay” is parallel to the clause, “it would be for a time, times, and half a time” (in its Old Testament source, Daniel 12:7). Elsewhere (Rev. 12:6, 14) it appears that 1,260 days (3.5 years with a 360 day year) is parallel to “a time, times, and half a time.” This coupled with the many times in Revelation when it appears that Revelation unfolds the fulfillment of Daniel’s end-times prophesies (including his seventy weeks of 9:24-27, that include the last week divided into two halves of 3.5 years)—and the strong indications that Revelation deals with events of this current inter-advent age—all suggests that the 3.5 years (and the implied seven years if we consider its doubling in Daniel) is a symbolic use of numbers. See also in Rev. 11:3, 9, 11, where 1,260 days (v. 3) is used in conjunction with 3.5 days (vv. 9, 11), in the context of the witness of God in this inter-advent age proclaiming God’s word and also being killed, but also be raised. When all this is put together, the 3.5 years or the 7 (if doubled) are pictures of trials, tribulations, that take place throughout this present age (although they are intensified toward the end). The 3.5 years also has special significance as roughly the same period of time Antiochus Epiphanes greatly persecuted the people of God and desecrated the temple a couple centuries before the days of Jesus. 

(8) In 11:9 the “three and a half days,” understood in context, is symbolic—meaning a short period of time and most likely drawing upon the parallel between the saints’ death and resurrection, and that of Jesus. It also is contrasted with the 3.5 years of v. 2—as a much shorter period. 

(9)  In 11:13 we find the statement, “there was a great earthquake, and a tenth of the city fell. Seven thousand people were killed,” is clearly symbolic. The inference is that 1/10 = 7,000, which means 70,000 people = the total population. That much too low for Jerusalem or any other literal city to which this could refer. At the same time, the presence of 7 and 70 (7x10) all suggests completion or fullness. In other words, this is the city of fear-inspiring nations (cf. Is. 25:3). 

(10) In 13:18 the number of the beast (666), which also equals his name, expresses this full state of being incomplete and evil. Though the dragon-beast-false prophet seek to be a counterfeit Triune God and Savior, they fall short, they are incomplete. They, working on humanity and like humanity (sinful) mark and rule their followers and their followers share in their character. These are all intended as symbolic depictions. 

(11) What we see from this list is that Revelation has a strong tendency for using numbers in the same manner it does many other things—symbolically. Again, we are not reading this into the book so that we can make it say something we desire it to say. Rather, we are deriving this from the book itself, seen in accordance with its structure, in light of Old Testament background, and in some cases in accordance with clear use of symbolism in numbers in some cases. Where this will become very significant in reference to a large current debate is when we get to the “thousand years” of Revelation 20:2, 4, 5, 6. If we discover there is strong evidence in that text and its context for understanding that number symbolically and to refer to a current period of time that spans from the first to second coming of Christ (which is what we will affirm when we get there), we are not all of a sudden treating numbers in a way that runs counter to how John uses them elsewhere in Revelation.

Joyfully Working Through Revelation With You,
Tom

Monday, January 8, 2018

Courage To Step Off The Cliff (Revelation 1:4-8)


A truth that emerges from the pages of Revelation over and over again is that the nature of the church is to live on mission. In our congregation we talk about living for the glory of God as Joyful followers who know, grow in, serve, and share Jesus Christ so others can do the same. This means that, as we run around the bases of life, we will be involved not only in serving others in some meaningful way, but also sharing with them how they can come to know and grow in, serve, and share Jesus also. 

Yet, we all know living on mission is usually not easy. Whether Christians are facing persecution for their faith or whether they are simply afraid of how others will react to them, it is easy to feel as if living on mission is like stepping off a cliff. How can we gain the courage?  

Since this is an important purpose of Revelation, John points the way to this courage in four main ways as he greets the churches to whom he is writing in Revelation 1:4-8.  

1. We Find Power And Peace That Comes From Our God. 4-5a

John lets readers know right away that this power and peace are available to the Church throughout the world in all ages, as he writes, “John to the seven churches that are in Asia.” We discovered last week we can expect a great deal of symbolism in Revelation, including in the use of numbers. Most likely John did in fact write and send this entire prophetic letter work to the seven churches he mentions here and in chapters two-three. However, it also is most likely that the seven churches represent the universal church. We know at that time there were more than seven churches in Asia Minor (what is today southern Turkey). Why did he address these seven, no more, and no less? At least part of the answer may be that he wanted to signify something with these seven churches. This leads to the next point. 

We also see in Revelation that the number 7 has a symbolic meaning—suggesting fullness (see later in 1:4, as well as the seven seals, seven trumpets, seven symbolic histories, and seven bowl judgments of chapters 6-16, as well as Gen. 2:2-3; Lev. 25:8). Most likely the addresses to these seven churches are intended to speak to the Church worldwide, and so this power and peace are given by God to all true believers throughout the world and throughout history.  

Next, in his greeting, John expresses his desire, i.e. his prayer, for all who read Revelation: That we would experience God’s saving and transforming unmerited power, as well as the wholeness of life also known as peace: “Grace to you and peace.” As we will see shortly, these divinely-originated resources are, in part, so we can live on mission.  

To begin, this grace and peace come from God the Father: “from him who is and who was and who is to come.” Based upon similar phrases found in Isaiah (Is. 41:4; 43:10; 44:6; 48:12) that appear to have originated in Exodus 3:14 and the statements there on the divine name, this description of God emphasizes that he is the self-existent, ever-present God who is able to do all that he promises. This is especially true of the part of the description, “the one who is.” Additionally, because it appears again in 1:8 in conjunction with “the Alpha and Omega” (a name that emphasizes God is the origin of all the world and history and controls the end of all things, as well as all in between), and in conjunction with “the Almighty,” the two last parts of the description, “who was and is to come,” emphasize that God is in control in, over, and behind all things. He is absolutely sovereign. He also is all-powerful. 

So, to know that grace and peace can and do come from such a God is to know that we have great resources! 

Next, John expresses his desire or his prayer that this grace and peace also come from the third person of God, the Holy Spirit: “and from the seven spirits who are before his throne.” Because of other trinitarian prayers for (or statements of) God’s resources elsewhere in the New Testament (e.g. 2 Cor. 13:14; Phil. 2:1), there can be little doubt, sandwiched in between God the Father and also Jesus Christ, this reference is to the Holy Spirit. Here the Spirit is depicted as the perfect and full Spirit, the one who is perfectly capable of empowering saints in whatever way is needed. This reference to the Holy Spirt also is an allusion to Zechariah 4:2-9 where Zechariah receives a vision of a lampstand with seven lamps on it that receives perpetual olive oil from nearby olive trees and symbolizes the continual empowerment the Spirit gives to the governor of Judah, Zerubbabel, and to others to rebuild the temple. In 4:6 we read: “Not by might, nor by power, but by my Spirit, says the Lord of hosts.” Likewise, John is being shown that the Spirit empowers those who are kings and priests (Rev. 1:6), the end-times temple of God (cf. 1:20).  

Yet, to emphasize that these divine resources come from all three persons in the one true and living God, John adds in verse 5: “and from Jesus Christ the faithful witness, the firstborn of the dead, and the ruler of kings on earth.” Here, readers are reminded that Jesus has gone before us as a faithful witness to God the Father, to the plan of salvation, and to all that the Father had wanted him to communicate (John 1:1-18; Heb. 1:1-3; Rev. 1:10)—even in the face of great trials and persecution! He is not calling us to do anything that he himself has not already done (see John 20:21!).  

Yet, it is not only as an example that Jesus Christ can help us to be faithful witnesses. He also can do this since he is the firstborn from the dead (which means that his resurrection leads to our resurrection). Because Jesus conquered sin and death, we can conquer it and live out true resurrected life now. And, we go out into the world with the power of and representing one who is “the ruler of the kings of the earth” (see also 17:14; 19:16). Usually in Revelation this kind of reference to kings speaks of those in opposition to Jesus Christ, so the focus is upon this age we now live in (when there still is opposition) and not the age to come (when there is none). Because this is true of Jesus, he can empower and take care of us in the ultimate sense so that nothing or no one can separate us from our eternal reward, his protection, or his love (Rom. 8:31-39), and so that we can carry out our mission faithfully and fruitfully.   

Additionally, we need to see in these three descriptions of Jesus Christ (“faithful witness,” “firstborn of the dead,” and “the ruler of kings of the earth”) John is alluding to Psalm 89:27, 37, where all three phrases are used to speak of the king who will rule over his enemies and whose seed will sit on his throne forever. Jesus Christ is the one who brought and started this new kingdom and the new creation that transforms and empowers us.  

So, the reality we can have such grace and peace from this God—the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit—is no small thing. As we go out into the world to give testimony to Jesus Christ, we do so in the greatest power known to man—that of the infinite eternal God!  He will never command us to do something that he does not also give us the more-than-sufficient-ability to do.  

The mention of Jesus Christ leads John to break into a word of praise in the rest of verse five and into six. As John does this, he also expresses the second way we can have courage. 

2. We Live For The Glory Of The One Who Saved Us, Jesus Christ, And Can Live For His Glory Because He Saved Us. 5b-6

That John is breaking into praise is evident from what we read at the beginning and end of these statements: “To him…to him be glory and dominion forever and ever. Amen.” Whenever we see this form (e.g. Eph. 3:20-21), it suggests that the person breaks into a statement of a desire to give God glory (here to God the Son), and then must also state what has moved him to do so. For John here, it is the reality that that Jesus “continually loves us and freed us from our sins by his blood and made us a kingdom, priests to his God and Father.”  

John not only celebrates the love of Christ that motivated his saving work, but the fact that he has freed his people from the penalty of sin, is freeing them from the power of sin, and someday will free them from the presence of sin—and all this through his substitutionary atoning death on the cross.  

Yet, it is not just forgiveness of sin and eternal life which motivates John’s praise, it is also that, as a result, we are part of his kingdom and are priests who serve him and thus bring others to know him! The wording of verse 6 (“and made us a kingdom, priests to his God and Father”) is an allusion to Exodus 19:6 and what God said of Israel after he brought them out of their Egyptian bondage and when they were at Mt. Sinai. As kings and priests, Israel was to be a light to the nations, but they failed. Revelation clarifies that what Israel failed to do, the new and true Israel (Jew and Gentile), that is, the New Testament Church, will carry out (see also Rev. 5:10; 11:7).  

If there were any doubt that this passage was providing courage and strength for mission, it should now be removed. John highlights that Jesus’ salvation of us results in our living on mission. And John praises him for this! 

The third way John points to the courage we can have as we live on mission is found in verse seven.  

3. We Focus On The Certain Coming Of Jesus Christ And The Fulfillment Of All God’s Promises. 7

Here John writes: “Behold, he is coming with the clouds, and every eye will see him, even those who pierced him, and all tribes of the earth will wail on account of him. Even so. Amen.” Here John not only seems to be emphasizing that Jesus’s first and second comings start and complete the fulfillments of that to which Old Testament authors looked forward (Dan. 7:13; Zech. 12:10), but also is calling our minds to the certainty of God fulfilling all he promises to us in Christ. 

What this means is that God will not only enable the Church to fulfill her mission and that includes whatever part God has determined each saint play in that mission, but he will also preserve, protect, and reward his people as he promises throughout Revelation, and will bring them into his blessed and favorable presence forever (Rev. 21-22).  

The final way John points us to the way of courage is in verse 8.  

4. We Find Courage In The Knowledge Of Our Almighty God. 8

John writes: “‘I am the Alpha and Omega,’ says the Lord God, ‘who is and who was and who is to come, the Almighty.’” 

Since we focused upon these descriptions in verse four, we don’t need to repeat here what we said. The main point is as Jesus said in Matthew 19:26: “With God all things are possible.”  

Too often, when we think about serving and sharing Jesus Christ so that others can come to know, grow in, serve, and share him also, we conclude that it is something we have to make happen. We are confident or we lack confidence based upon what we ourselves can or cannot do. 

What John encourages us to do in these five verses is to look beyond and outside ourselves, to our triune God and the work he has done, is doing, and will do in us. Our living on mission is more about what he can do through us than what we can do for him! 

This is an emphasis that is started here and runs throughout the book of Revelation.  

So, step off the cliff with courage! 

Joyfully And Courageously Living On Mission With You, 

Tom

Monday, January 1, 2018

Start With The Instructions: Revelation 1:1-3


Welcome to my first blog post of 2018 and our inaugural post that will help us study through the book of Revelation together this year. Over the past two to three years, as I spent much time in this last book of the New Testament, I have been deeply impacted and blessed. I also have found it to be far more practical, powerful, penetrating, and praise-producing than what I previously believed. I pray these will be your experiences also.

This coming Sunday we will look at Revelation 1:1-3:
The revelation of Jesus Christ, which God gave him to show to his servants the things that must soon take place. He made it known by sending his angel to his servant John, 2 who bore witness to the word of God and to the testimony of Jesus Christ, even to all that he saw. 3 Blessed is the one who reads aloud the words of this prophecy, and blessed are those who hear, and who keep what is written in it, for the time is near.

There are several truths that emerge from this introduction to the book that will provide instructions and direction for how to understand Revelation and apply it. In the midst of them, we also will come across some very important words of application for now.

1. This Book Is About Jesus Christ: “The Revelation Of Jesus Christ”
Right off the bat we find out these pages, more than anything else, unveil, they uncover, they bring to the forefront, Jesus Christ. This last book of the New Testament, just like the entire Bible, has Jesus Christ as the central figure. If our understanding of these twenty-two chapters somehow sets him aside, we have misunderstood them.

These first four words of the English text (first two words in the Greek text) also remind us that Bible intake is best done and life (Think: work, recreation, marriage, parenting, rest) is best lived out with Jesus Christ at the center, as our hope, our resource of power, or focus, and our ultimate goal! 

2. This Book Is From God: “Which God Gave Him”
Here is an interesting statement. Though the book is about the second person of God, the Son who became man, it is God the Father who gave to the Son the things about Jesus Christ that should be revealed in these pages. This not only emphasizes the divine origin of the book, but also highlights both the Father and the Son are involved in communicating it. We will learn later in the book (chapters 4-5) that the sovereign plan and work of both the Father and Son are behind what is revealed in this book and what takes place in this world—with special emphasis on what happens between the first coming of Jesus Christ and his second coming, which leads into the future eternal age.

Herein we find a good reminder, to approach the Word of God as just what it is: From God, all of it (2 Tim. 3:16-17). And so, it is authoritative, useful, and should be our ultimate source for truth and wisdom upon which we build all of life. 

3. This Book Reveals How Old Testament Prophecies Are Being Fulfilled During This Present Age: “To Show His Servants The Things That Must Soon Take Place.” 
The clause “the things that must soon take place,” seems to be parallel to the statement in Rev. 1:19, lit. “the things that are about to be after these things.” That statement is surely dependent upon the Greek translation of Daniel 2:29, which reads, “the things that must be after these things” (which is parallel to the Daniel 2:28 statement in the Greek translation: “the things that must be in the last days”). Both of those statements are on the lips of Daniel as he prepares to give messages to king Nebuchadnezzar about the future end times.  All John has done is to substitute “soon” for “after these things” or “in the last days.” What appears to be communicated here is this: What Daniel saw in visions that looked far into the distance, John is now seeing as beginning. In other words, the end-times or last days have arrived (Rom. 10:11; Heb. 1:3)!

So, John, living at the end of the first century, AD, was at the beginning of the end-times fulfillments of what Old Testament prophets had looked into the distance to see.

This suggests that Revelation is not primarily about what had already happened before the days John is writing (what some call the Preterist view of Revelation), nor is it looking to the distant future to see only what happens at the very end of this age and leading into the next age (what some call the futurist view—a view that was popularized in the Left Behind series). Rather, the best approach to Revelation is one that sees it revealing what is happening throughout the Church age (the very time in which we are now living)—and on through the Second Coming into eternity future.

The approach to Revelation I believe best fits the book’s content and structure is what some have called the Redemptive-Historical-Idealist view. Simply-put, as the ESV Study Bible explains this approach in the Introduction to Revelation, “Revelation’s visions symbolize the conflict between Christ and his church on the one hand, and Satan and his evil conspirators on the other, from the apostolic age to Christ’s second coming.”

I believe the book, after sharing the vision of Christ in chapter 1 that makes the point he is present among the church to empower for mission, to rebuke when they stray, and to help in the face of persecution, then in chapters 2-3 gives comfort and correction flowing out of that vision to the universal church (represented by the seven churches of Asia Minor [present day western Turkey]), then affirms in chapters 4-5 that the Father and Son are sovereign over history and, therefore, all that is happening in this age flows from their sovereign plan, as well as out of the saving work of Christ. Then, in chapters 6-20 we find six different pictures of the outworking of God’s salvation of his people, his protection of them in the face of persecution, and his judgment upon unbelievers from the first coming to second coming of Christ. Each picture recaps the pictures before it, but also adds different elements and moves us closer and closer to a more detailed understanding of the age we are living in, why we face a hostile culture, and how we can remain faithful to God. Then, in the climactic conclusion to the book (chapters 21-22) we see the future certain hope of the true Church, the new heaven and new earth, which is designed to motivate us to persevere in this age now. 

4. The Book Is Highly Symbolic: "He Made It known By Sending His Angel To His Servant John." 

 The clause the ESV translates, “he made it known,” is better translated, “he signified it” or “he symbolized it.” The verb used is sēmainō. Its noun form, sēmeion, was used over and over again by John in the Gospel of John to refer to Jesus’ miracles. John’s point there was that Jesus’ miracles gave signs of other truths. In other words, they signified or symbolized the gospel. The visions that John receives in Revelation give pictures. We might say what John “literally” sees is often not intended to be taken in a literal way to gain the message. For example, in ch. 1 John receives a vision of the risen and glorified Jesus Christ. However, the point is not that this is what Jesus literally looks like now. The point is for the reader to see the depictions of Jesus in light of their Old Testament backgrounds and to understand them as symbolizing truths about Jesus. 

The book of Revelation also belongs to a genre of literature known as apocalyptic, which virtually all scholars have recognized as being very symbolic in nature. So, this is another reason to expect a figurative, not a literal book. 

Please don’t misunderstand what I am saying. To affirm Revelation is highly symbolic is not to say that we can make the symbols mean whatever we want them to mean and so the message of Revelation is whatever a reader desires. No, there is one intended meaning for each unit of communication. And the symbols are almost always understood by looking at their vast Old Testament background, as well as by seeing them in the context and structure of Revelation itself. 

Our goal in Revelation will not be to interpret it as our favorite pastor did, like our parents did, or to seek some literal understanding. The goal is to find the divinely inspired meaning that John intends in his writing of it. We can expect that to be highly symbolic or figurative. 

As we go through the book, we will also provide much more support for a symbolic or figurative understanding of the book, such as a figurative use of numbers. 

5. The Human Author Of The Book Is John The Apostle: “He Made It Known By Sending His Angel to His Servant John.”
The writer identifies himself as “John” (see 1:1, 4, 9; 22:8) and since he did not feel a need to explain more about his identify, he was a well-known John. The readers simply knew who he was. Being such a well-known leader would fit the Apostle John. Additionally, several second century church leaders referred to the Apostle John as the author of Revelation, not the least of which was Irenaeus, who heard Polycarp preach when he was young and Polycarp was a disciple of the Apostle John.

This means that the author of Revelation is the same as the author of John and also 1, 2, and 3 John. This is supported by the fact we see some similar uses of words among these works. Some scholars emphasize that there is too much difference between Revelation and these other New Testament books to be written by the same author. We must, however, keep in mind that Revelation is a very different kind of genre than these other books. The difference in genre could just as easily account for the differences rather than there being a different author.

6. The Book Represents A Sound Witness To What John Saw: “Who Bore Witness To The Word Of God and To The Testimony Of Jesus Christ, Even To All That He Saw.”
Here we discover that John received the “Word of God,” which means it is authoritative communication from God (words that are faithful and true: See 19:9; 21:5). These words also are a testimony about Jesus Christ, which we should expect, since it is a “revelation of Jesus Christ” (see 1:1). Finally, we learn here that John bore witness to all he saw (in the context of the book this means he bore faithful witness to what he saw!), which reminds us that the vast majority of what he received was in the form of visions. We need to keep this in mind as we interpret some of the strange images. They are what John saw in the visions. Yet, they are meant to symbolize some truth(s), rather than necessarily to be taken literally. 

7. Happiness Is Promised To Those Who Read And Follow The Truths In Revelation: “Blessed Is The One Who Reads Aloud The Words Of This Prophecy, And Blessed Are Those Who Hear, And Who Keep What Is Written In It, For The Time Is Near.”
The word translated, “blessed” (makarios in Greek) is better translated as “happy” than “blessed.” There are seven such beatitudes throughout Revelation that teach the following. In 16:15 we learn that those who persevere in righteousness and faithfulness and so are ready for the coming of Christ, they are happy. This is in addition to pronouncing God’s grace-produced happiness upon those who read, hear, and keep the words of this prophecy (1:3; 22:7); those who have washed robes and thus have eternal life (22:14); those who die in Christ (14:13); those who are effectively called to the marriage supper of the Lamb (19:9); and those who have been raised or graduated in this age to be with Christ now (20:6).

But the truth captured in 1:3 is that the way to true happiness is to know and follow God’s Word. According to this promise, this especially includes the book of Revelation. 

My prayer is that we will put our hearts and minds prayerfully and diligently into the message of this book with the result we will realize the happiness that comes with it. 

I hope this prepares you not only for living as joyful followers in a hostile culture, but also for understanding more fully the first three verses of Revelation, and how to understand the entire book.

Joyfully Reading Revelation With You!

Tom

Saturday, December 30, 2017

Revelation Introduction: Glory In Marriage


Because I am a pastor, I have officiated at a lot of weddings. One part of the ceremony will never get old to me—watching the groom watch his bride come down the aisle. That slow stroll almost always draws out of the soon-to-be-husband a big smile. I imagine that he is usually thinking, “Wow! She’s beautiful and she will be my wife!  How in the world did she agree to marry me!”  That was certainly what I was thinking on my wedding day!

Another reason I love these scenes is because they picture for us an important and powerful part of the gospel, which announces to us there is coming a time when another groom, Jesus Christ, will smile with great delight, pleasure, and love as he sees his bride making her way toward him in the new heaven and earth. Consider what we read in Revelation 21:1-2: “Then I saw a new heaven and a new earth, for the first heaven and the first earth had passed away, and the sea was no more. 2 And I saw the holy city, new Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven from God, prepared as a bride adorned for her husband.”

There are seven joy-producing truths that verse two moves us to think about in relation to that future groom and bride.

1. Verse 2 is not just talking about a place, but more to the point, it pictures God’s people, his bride. We know this because in Revelation 3:12 it is promised by Jesus Christ to the one who conquers in the midst of a hostile and persecuting culture: “I will make him a pillar in the temple of my God. Never shall he go out of it, and I will write on him the name of my God, and the name of the city of my God, the new Jerusalem, which comes down from my God out of heaven, and my own new name.” Additionally, in Revelation 20:9 God’s people are referred to as “the camp of the saints, even the beloved city” (which refers to Jerusalem).  You see, in the Old Testament “Jerusalem” or “Mt. Zion” often referred to the place where God dwelt with his people in a more realized and outward way to bless them. This terminology in the New Testament is applied to God’s people with whom he is present (see Heb. 12:22; Rev. 14:1). Also, the fact that the “bride” refers to God’s people and not just a place will also be seen below from the Old Testament background to this passage.

 2. Unlike grooms and brides we see at a wedding today, this future groom (Jesus Christ) will not be standing there looking at his beautiful bride in a passive sense. You see, almost no merely human groom has anything to do with the beauty of his bride. He simply gets to enjoy and delight in the gift given to him. Yet, with our Savior, he has everything to do with the beauty of his bride. We know this because the word translated “prepared” (the Greek word hetoimazō) conveys the reality that ultimately the bride has been prepared by another in the past with the result she continues to be prepared. It is true the same verb is used in Revelation 19:7 to say that the bride prepared herself for the bridegroom. Yet, there it also says she was able to do this because it had first been graciously given to her to do by God (19:8). Christ’s bride, the Church, is able to be transformed by the renewing of her mind (Rom. 12:1-2) because of God’s transforming grace that is ours in and through Jesus Christ (Rom. 1:1-11:36).

3. The preparation of this future bride, like most any bride we would see today, involves being beautified for the big day. In Revelation 21:2 we read that this bride is “adorned (from the Greek verb kosmeō) for her husband. In other words, she is put in order, given a cosmetic makeover so she is ready for her husband, most likely to bring him joy and, in this case, to honor him. Like the preparation, this cosmetic makeover is not something she merely does to herself, but can take place because the Savior has been transforming her. This beautification of the bride is primarily ethical (helping her conform to the will of God and to be conformed to the likeness of Christ: cf. Rom. 8:29; 12:1-2; Eph. 4:22-24) and doxological (i.e. helping her to worship God as she ought to: cf. Rev. 5:9-10; 14:1-5). More detailed meaning behind this preparation and adornment is also found in the Old Testament background to this verse. This lead us to the next point to ponder from Rev. 21:2.

4. The Old Testament background for the thread of teaching in Rev. 3:12 and 21:2 is found in Isaiah 62:1-4, which reads: “For Zion's sake I will not keep silent, and for Jerusalem's sake I will not be quiet, until her righteousness goes forth as brightness, and her salvation as a burning torch. 2The nations shall see your righteousness, and all the kings your glory, and you shall be called by a new name that the mouth of the Lord will give. 3You shall be a crown of beauty in the hand of the Lord, and a royal diadem in the hand of your God. 4You shall no more be termed Forsaken, and your land shall no more be termed Desolate, but you shall be called My Delight Is in Her, and your land Married; for the Lord delights in you, and your land shall be married.”

The book of Isaiah makes clear to Judah they are heading into captivity because of their rebellion and sin (cf. 39:6-7), yet, God will save and restore them after this (ch’s. 40-66). He will do this by sending his suffering Servant to atone for them (52:13-53:12; 61:1-2). Once this Redeemer comes, empowered by the Spirit, he will not only save, but also transform God’s people so that the glory of the Lord shines through them and draws the nations to God (59:19-62:12).

Specifically, here in Is. 62:1-4, we discover that God is taking an unfaithful lewd bride (who had been forsaken by her husband for her behavior) and he is restoring her, giving her a new name, and transforming her ethically and doxologically so that nations and kings will see this new glory. The new glory will draw nations and kings to the true God, and this is why the nations and kings will be present in the new heaven and new earth (Rev. 21:24-26). What we discover, then, in Revelation 21:2 is the ultimate fulfillment of Isaiah’s prophecy. Because the Church has been saved and sanctified—and so she has lived on mission as a transformed bride—nations and kings have been won! Here in Is. 62:1-4 the focus is on initial and progressive sanctification (her initial and ongoing preparation and adornment). The picture in Revelation 21:2 is the finished and fully completed result! She, the Church, is beautiful, radiant with the very glory of God, and redounding to his glory!

5. An interesting background to Isaiah 62:1-4 and the fact that the new name for God’s people is “My delight is in her” (Hephzibah), is this: By the time Isaiah wrote this prophecy, Manasseh (Judah’s most horrific, evil, and idolatrous king) was on the throne. He had certainly made the situation in Judah even more grievous than it had previously been. In 2 Kings 21:2 we learn that the name of Manasseh’s mother, the wife of the good king, Hezekiah, was “Hephzibah.” What Isaiah is saying to Judah in Isaiah 62:1-4 (esp. to the genuine believers who would either remember the reign of the good king and the name of his wife or they would at least have heard about it) is that in the future God will save and return them from their evil and idolatry to a place of fidelity to him and to a state in which God’s delight truly is in them (his bride).

6. If the content of Isaiah 62:1-4 that goes beyond the bride picture is also to be read into Rev. 21:2 (which is often how Old Testament quotes in the New Testament work, especially in Revelation), what we see here is God’s people finally fulfilling the initial purpose of mankind, and that is to serve as kings and queens, vice-regents, who serve and reign under God as those who are created in God’s image and crowned with his glory and honor—which results in their reflecting that glory and honor as God-glorifiers. This also shows that the bride in Rev. 21:2 also reigns underneath the triune God (she is a royal bride!) and redounds to his glory!

7. Finally, we can say that most likely part of the reason God created marriage (based on the line of thought in Eph. 5:32 and seen in light of what we have just presented) is to help display this picture: All of us are part of the lewd bride of Christ whom the Savior saves, transforms, sanctifies, and beautifies and he does this for his glory and joy (see Rev. 21:2 [“for her husband”] in light of the OT background). Whenever we see a bride walking down the aisle toward her bridegroom and we see his joy and delight displayed, this reflects that storyline. It reflects it whether she is a virgin (which is the kind of purity to which God restores to his people [cf. Rev. 14:1-5]) or if she is not a virgin, yet now has been taken into the love and into the holy matrimony she is entering with her spouse.

Bottom-line, what we have, then, is the encouraging good news of how God is graciously working in us to beautify us ethically and doxologically for his joy and glory, as well as for our joy also!  I pray we will never again attend a wedding without thinking about this glorious hope we have in Christ.

Joyfully Being Transformed With You In Christ!

Tom

Sunday, November 12, 2017

What Is Molinism?

It was May of 1973 and I was two months shy of twelve years old. Our small United Methodist Church in Indiana had invited an evangelist, Y. D. Westerfield, from Asbury College in Wilmore, Kentucky, to preach at special evening meetings for the week. I was not at all excited about it because my mom wanted me to attend. I hated going to church. I was finishing sixth grade, loved baseball, was very much drawn to the model of a family member who told me of his wild escapades when he was a boy, and so I would sneak a baseball into Sunday morning services with me, I would try and sit at the end of a pew and look at the window, and I would dream of more exciting things I could be doing. I had no interest in what was being said at regular Sunday services, and certainly no interest in going to more services where there was more preaching!
But there were movements, things going on behind the scenes of which I was unaware. My mom was fervently praying for her youngest child. She knew I was heading down a path that was away from God. There was also a desire in my heart for my life to be significant. And, as much as I tried to snuff it out, there was sensitivity to what was right and wrong. Little did I know that, as C.S. Lewis famously described his own conversion, the great fisherman in the sky had his hook in my mouth and was reeling me into the boat.

 I do not remember anything that the Rev. Westerfield preached that week, but I do remember that at one of the services this eleven year old boy came under great conviction of his sin, realized he was on his way to hell, and wanted nothing more than to “gain Christ” (Phil. 3:8). That time is such a sweet memory for me, for it was as if light filled the vast and dark cavern of my soul. And from then on I wanted nothing more than to serve my Savior. Oh how I loved him and his Church from that day!

Yet, as I think back on that evening, the events that led up to it, the events that transpired afterward, and even of the other people who were present, so many questions arise. If God answered the prayers of my mom and worked mightily in my heart so that I would trust in Christ, in what way did my faith and repentance comprise free decisions on my part? If the Spirit of God placed within me a desire to please God, in what ways could my subsequent desires, decisions, and actions to obey God be free? If all these decisions were free on my part, in what way can we say that the sovereign God was governing me and my actions through his providence—that salvation was ultimately of him? And finally, what about other people who were present, those who heard the same messages and did not respond? Maybe some of them never responded. Are their actions free? Was God also governing them?

Molinism posits middle knowledge as a way of bringing together God’s sovereignty and man’s responsibility to answer such questions—and doing this in such a way that claims to preserve libertarian human freedom. The Molinist would say that little Tommy Barnes, in 1973, was governed by God in a strong way that he was certain to trust in Jesus Christ, but at the same time, his faith and repentance were not determined, and in such a way, at the same time, he could also have rejected Christ.

 Since many readers are not familiar with Molinism’s history, let’s take a look at how it arose.

The Origin Of Molinism
Luis de Molina was a sixteenth century (born in 1535) Spanish Jesuit Counter-Reformer.[1] The Roman Catholic theologian was both committed to God’s “prevenient grace, which stirs and solicits the will of man…[that] may be either accepted or resisted by the human will”[2] and also was troubled by the sense that God’s infallible foreknowledge, implicit in those who followed the approach of Thomas of Aquinas and explicit in the Protestant Reformers, denied libertarian freedom.[3] Molina described this freedom in this way: “…given the same disposition and cognition on the part of the intellect, the will is by its innate freedom able to will or to dissent or to neither will nor dissent.”[4]

The problem Molina faced can be illustrated in this manner. If God infallibly knows that Tommy Barnes will go to a special service in May of 1973 and trust in Jesus Christ as Savior, then Tommy Barnes will certainly do that. As a result, there is some sense in which Tommy is unable to avoid this, which would seem to deny libertarian free will. Yet, if Tommy truly were able to make another choice that night at the special service, then God’s foreknowledge is not infallible.
Molina and modern Molinists have rejected Open-Theism, Simple Foreknowledge Arminianism, and Calvinism in favor of a fourth approach, one that includes “middle knowledge.” This doctrine must be understood in light of the categories theologians used in Molina’s day. Both followers of Aquinas and Reformed Theologians distinguished between natural (or necessary) and free knowledge.[5] In the 17th c. Reformed theologian, Francis Turretin, for example, spoke of both natural and free knowledge—arguing these encompassed all the knowledge God had.[6]  Some Reformed theologians still speak of the logical moments of God’s natural and free knowledge.[7] Molina argued for a third kind of knowledge God possessed: Molina and his followers have set forth three logical moments in the life of God, which can be diagrammed as follows: [8]

[Logical] Moment 1: God’s natural knowledge of everything that could be.

[Logical] Moment 2: God’s middle knowledge of everything that would be.

Divine Decree[9]

[Logical] Moment 3: God’s free knowledge of everything that will happen in the actual world.”
Let’s look more closely at these three kinds of knowledge according to the Molinist model.

A Closer Look At Molinism
God’s natural or necessary knowledge is his knowledge of all that could happen, in other words, the possible worlds that could be. This knowledge:
…refers to that part of God’s knowledge which he knows by his very nature…. Included here is God’s knowledge of all metaphysically necessary truths and all possible truths. Thus natural knowledge, properly conceived, is that part of God’s knowledge which could not have been different from what it is. It follows from this that the content of God’s natural knowledge is independent of his will…. [Natural knowledge is] logically prior to any act of will on God’s part….[10]

Thus, what is being asserted in God’s natural knowledge is that, “He knows all possibilities, everything that could happen…. These fully formed possible scenarios are generally called possible worlds. There is an infinite upon infinite number of possible permutations of how things could have been.”[11] What is more, “a central feature of God’s natural knowledge is that the content of this knowledge is essential to God; indeed this is why such knowledge is natural. It does not depend on God’s will, but necessarily belongs to God’s omniscience.”[12] In other words, God, by his very nature, has this knowledge.[13]

The second kind of knowledge that theologians of the Middle Ages, as well as Molina, posited is God’s free knowledge—his knowledge of the world that he did make and all that will happen, all that will be actualized in that world. “The free knowledge of God comprehends everything that has/is/will happen in this existent and contingent world.”[14] It is called “free” since it is based upon God’s free decision to create the world that is and not another. It is also called free because it “has its source solely in his mind and will.”[15] In other words, free knowledge:

…refers to that part of God’s knowledge which he knows by his creative act of will. Included here are truths which refer to what actually exists (or will exist). Since free knowledge comes from God’s creative act of will, it follows that the content of that knowledge is contingent. It includes only metaphysically contingent truths, or truths that could have been prevented by God, if he had chosen to create different situations, different creatures, or not to create at all. Thus, free knowledge can be characterized as dependent upon or logically posterior to God’s will.[16]

Molina and Molinists assert that God freely chose to “actualize” the world that is, and, “Of the infinite possibilities available to God, He was under no compulsion to choose this one. Yet He chose a world that contains free moral agents—angels and humans—who make genuinely free decisions”[17]—namely, the world that is. “According to the theory, middle knowledge is similar to natural knowledge in that it is prevolitional, or prior to God’s choice to create and therefore its truth is independent of God’s determining will. Likewise, it is similar to free knowledge in that the truths that are known are contingent (not necessary) because, in the mind of the Molinist, they are dependent on creaturely will.”[18]

William Lane Craig explains how the three kinds of knowledge relate:

For example, [God] knows whether Peter, if he were placed in certain circumstances, would deny Christ three times. By his natural knowledge God knew in the first moment all the possible things that Peter could do if placed in such circumstances. But now in this second moment he knows what Peter would in fact freely choose to do under such circumstances. This is not because Peter would be causally determined by the circumstances to act in this way. But God knows which way Peter would freely choose. God’s knowledge of Peter in this respect is not simple foreknowledge. For maybe God will decide not to place Peter under such circumstances or even not to create him at all. Middle knowledge, like natural knowledge, thus is logically prior to the decision of the divine will to create a world.[19]

Given only natural knowledge and free knowledge, according to the Molinist, there is not sufficient explanation of God’s knowledge to posit why he made the world he did and why or how his manner of creation preserves libertarian human freedom and also how it successfully addresses the issue of pain and evil (why did God create a world in which there is sin?). So, Middle knowledge is affirmed, which is God’s comprehension of all that would happen if certain things were different or if certain things were true.[20] In other words, “God’s middle knowledge comprehends everything that would happen if God had been willing to decree its occurrence.”[21]

To put it another way, this involves “God’s knowledge of possibilities involving human choice (the ‘counterfactuals of freedom’ as they have been called), ”[22] i.e. all counterfactuals of (libertarian) free choices.”[23] This knowledge allows God to know that if he made a different world than what he did, what would happen in that world.[24] So, for example, if God made a world in which the Jews and Jewish leaders of the first century had ignored Jesus, God knows what events and decisions would come out of such a world. He also knows if he made a world in which those same Jewish leaders and Jews had accepted Jesus as Messiah, what events and decisions would come about as a result. God also knows what would have happened with Tommy Barnes had the United Methodist Church in Belleville, Indiana not invited a special speaker to hold special services in May of 1973.

“The content of God’s middle knowledge can be seen as a virtually infinite number of propositions of the form, ‘If person P were in situation S, then P would freely perform action A.’”[25]
Kenneth Keathley adds: “An important note to make…is that God does not perceive what free creatures would do, but rather He conceives their choices within Himself. That is, God does not look forward in time to ascertain what decisions [people] would make; instead He innately knows all free choices due to his omniscience.”[26] Keathley adds that “the source of that knowledge is not the creature…[but] God Himself.”[27]

So, this is an introduction into the view known as Molinism. Coming into contact with this view has been the catalyst for my going back and revisiting divine sovereignty and human freedom. In our next blog I will briefly touch upon some strong points of Molinism and also introduce some problems.

Joyfully Exploring Divine Sovereignty And Human Freedom With You,

Tom Barnes





[1] Travis James Campbell, “Middle Knowledge: A Reformed Critique” (accessed from monergism.com on April 20, 2015), 1; “Luis de Molina,” in Catholic Enclyclopedia (accessed at newadvent.org on April 20, 2015).

[2] William Lane Craig, “Middle Knowledge: A Calvinist-Arminian Rapprochement?” in Clark H. Pinnock, Ed., The Grace God God And The Will Of Man (Minneapolis: Bethany House Publishers, 1989), 141.

[3] For the reality Molina was motivated by the implications of Thomistic Theology and Reformed Theology, see Robert R. Cook, “God, Middle Knowledge, And Alternative Worlds,” Evangelical Quarterly, 62 (1990): 294. See also James R. White, The Potter’s Freedom (Amityville, NY: Calvary Press, 2000), 34.

[4] Liberi Arbitrii cum Gratiae Donis, Divina Praescientia, Providentia, Praedestinatione et Reprobatione Concordia, 4.2, cited in Campbell, “Middle Knowledge,” 1-2. This is a classic and typical way of describing libertarian or indeterministic freedom.
Keathley, Salvation, chapter 3, argues for what he wisely calls soft indeterminism, an indeterminism that is not absolute. Rather, choices, he recognizes, are limited by character—in the case of humans—and character in turn is shaped by previous choices. In this book I will argue for soft determinism.

[5] Campbell, “Middle Knowledge,” 4. See also John D. Laing, “The Compatibility Of Calvinism And Middle Knowledge,” JETS, 47, 3 (September 2004): 456; Craig, “Rapprochement?” 145; and William Lane Craig, The Only Wise God: The Compatibility Of Divine Foreknowledge And Human Freedom (Eugene, Oregon: Wipf And Stock Publishers, 199, repr.), 119ff.

[6]Francis Turretin, Institutes Of Elenctic Theology (3 vols.; ed. James T. Dennison Jr.; Trans. George Musgrave Giger; Phillipsburg, N.J.: Presbyterian & Reformed, 1992), 1:212-13, cited in Paul Helm, Terrance L. Tiessen,“Does Calvinism Have Room For Middle Knowledge? A Conversation,” WTJ, 71, 2 (Fall 2009): 437.

[7] Kenneth Keathley, Salvation And Sovereignty (Nashville: Broadman and Holman, Kindle Edition), 150. See also Louis Berkhof, Systematic Theology: New Combined Edition, vol. 2 (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1996), 102.

[8] The following diagram is taken from Campbell, “Middle Knowledge,” 2. Campbell adds: “One will find a similar diagram in William Lane Craig, What Does God Know? Reconciling Divine Foreknowledge And Human Freedom (Norcross, Ga.: Ravi Zacharias International Ministries, 2002), a popular booklet expounding Molinism.
That these three kinds of knowledge have a logical and not temporal relationship, see Craig, “Rapprochement?” 145; and William Lane Craig, The Only Wise God: The Compatibility Of Divine Foreknowledge And Human Freedom (Eugene, Oregon: Wipf And Stock Publishers, 1999, repr.), 129-130.

[9] By divine decree we mean God’s eternal purpose by which he has chosen all that will come to pass (the actual world with all its creatures, events and facts that exists).

[10] John D. Laing, “The Compatibility Of Calvinism And Middle Knowledge,” JETS, 47, 3 (September 2004): 456.
Craig, The Only Wise God, 129, explains that included in this natural knowledge are the “laws of logic.”

[11] Keathley, Salvation, ch. 1.

[12] Craig, “Rapprochement?” 146.

[13] Craig, The Only Wise God, 129.

[14] Campbell, Middle Knowledge,” 3.

[15] Paul Helm, “Molinism 101,” 1 (accessed from Ligonier ministries on April 22, 2013).

[16] Laing, “The Compatibility:” 456-57. See also Craig, “Rapprochement?” 146; Turretin, Elenctic, 1:212-13.

[17] Keathley, Salvation, ch. 1. As will be shown below, I believe that the Molinist position cannot consistently argue for such a free creative act of God and such free works of providence given their commitment to indeterministic human freedom.

[18] Laing, “The Compatibility,” 457. Andrew A. Postiff, “The Theological Viability of Middle Knowledge” ( A Paper Presented To  W. Combs For Seminar In Soteriology, Detroit Baptist Theological Seminary, 2006), 4, adds: “Natural knowledge does include possibilities, but middle knowledge further limits these possibilities to those which are in harmony with the free wills of creatures. And by the point that God’s free knowledge has been ‘settled,’ there are no more open possibilities, but God knows all circumstances and all the decisions that free creatures will make in them.”

[19] Craig, The Only Wise God, 130.

[20] This knowledge for God is posited based upon all the subjunctive conditionals in Scripture. Also, it is asserted that since God is omniscience, this omniscience would include all possible actions or outcomes that could happen if certain things were true.

[21] Campbell, Middle Knowledge,” 4.

[22] Helm, “Molinism,” 2; Campbell, “Middle Knowledge,” 4-5.

[23] Campbell, Middle Knowledge,” 5.
Keathley, Salvation, 35: “A counterfactual is a conditional statement that has two distinctive features: (1) It involves a condition that is contrary to fact….; and (2) it expresses a truth that belongs to this actual world.”
Craig, “The Middle Knowledge View:” 120: “Counterfactuals are conditional statements in the subjunctive mood….”

[24] Craig, “Rapprochement:” 147, further explains: “…[God] knew what Peter would do within any possible order of circumstances, then, given the decision of his will to bring about a certain set of circumstances, God knew what Peter [will] in fact do.”

[25] Laing, “The Compatibility:” 457. Laing adds: “It should be noted that the actual existence of P or the occurrence of S or A is not necessary for God to have this knowledge” according to the Molinist position.

[26] Keathley, Salvation, 39.

[27] Keathley, Salvation, 39. Craig, “Rapprochement:”147, cites Molina himself: “[God] saw in his own essence what each such will would do with its innate freedom were it to be placed in this or that or, indeed, in infinitely many orders of things—even though it would really be able, if it so willed, to do the opposite….”
Postiff, “The Theological Viability:” 4-5, adds that the Molinist asserts, “…God knows each creature so well that he knows what free choice the creature would make in any possible circumstance.” He then explains: “In the literature this is called the doctrine of supercomprehension.”
These assertions, in part, are set forth to answer the grounding objection set forth by some opponents of Molinism, namely that there is not sufficient ground for God to have middle knowledge in regard to all future truly free human choices and actions.