Sunday, September 22, 2019

How We Should Approach Climate Change And The Call To Reduce Radically Our Use Of Carbon Fuels

Recently World magazine writer, Onize Ohikere, reported the following about young people zealous to fight climate change:[1]
Millions of students around the world skipped school on Friday for a global climate change strike. The movement included more than 5,000 demonstrations in 156 countries, including Germany, Nigeria, and Tokyo. Young demonstrators held signs that read, “You are destroying our future,” and “There is no planet B.” In the United States, organizers expect more than 800 events. New York City Public Schools said parents could excuse their students to participate in the strike.
What spurred the demonstrations? Swedish teen Greta Thunberg started a smaller movement last year to encourage her peers to demand action from their leaders. This year’s protests precede a United Nations Climate Action Summit that kicks off Monday [Sept. 23] in New York.

This reminds us that unless a person is totally unplugged from television, news sources and periodicals, it is hard to remain unaware of the dire predictions about our planet due to climate change. Both the supposition that the climate has changed radically due to human influence and the predicted destructive consequences are communicated as facts and alleged as well-documented through scientific data, which suggests they cannot be doubted. Nor should they be ignored.

Consider some other recent examples:
  • “Earth is sick with multiple and worsening environmental ills killing millions of people yearly, a new U.N. report says. Climate change, a global major extinction of animals and plants, a human population soaring toward 10 billion, degraded land, polluted air, and plastics, pesticides and hormone-changing chemicals in the water are making the planet an increasing unhealthy place for people, says the scientific report issued once every few years…. Several other scientists also praised the report, which draws on existing science, data, and maps…. The scientists said the most important and pressing problems facing humankind are global warming and loss of biodiversity because they are permanent and affect so many people in so many different ways.”[2]
  • “Nature is in more trouble now than at any other time in human history, with extinction looming over 1 million species of plants and animals, scientists said today in the United Nations first comprehensive report on biodiversity. It’s all because of humans, but it’s not too late to fix the problem…. Conservation scientists from around the world convened in Paris to issue the report, which exceeded 1,000 pages. The Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services included more than 450 researchers who used 15,000 scientific and government reports…. The poor in less-developed-countries bear the greatest burden. The report’s 39-page summary highlighted ways people are reducing biodiversity…. Permitting climate change from the burning of fossil fuels to make it too hot, wet or dry for some species to survive. Almost half of the world’s land mammals—not including bats—and nearly a quarter of the birds already have had their habitats hit hard by global warming.”[3]
  • “I am a climate optimist, but it’s up to us to act fast—to stop burning fossil fuels right now and start transitioning to clean energy…. Based on the best scientific evidence available to date, we have less than 12 years to mobilize a complete conversion from fossil fuels to green energy, or we risk dangerously destabilizing Earth’s climate.”[4]
  • “I don’t make judgments. I just say the facts, that things are changing: 2017 was a devastating year for hurricanes. These things are happening. Call it what you want, but we need to look at the environment and we need to talk about it.”[5]
What is interesting about these examples is that they all come within a period of just a few months in the kinds of main-line sources to which most persons have access. They represent the ongoing catechesis that has resulted in convincing the minds of the average person. What are the convictions to which many have come and that are implied in these examples?
  • There is currently significant climate change that is the result of human actions. Science has allegedly proven this. 
  • This significant change is seen in weather patterns throughout the earth, such as the increase in severity and number of hurricanes. 
  • This significant change will have dire consequences upon people (especially the poor) and upon animals and plants. 
  • The main culprit in climate change is the use of fossil fuels by humans. 
  • The way to turn around these trends and to prevent devastation of the earth is to engage in radical reductions in fossil fuels right away. 
There are multiple motivations for Christians to take note of and to be involved in environmental issues. The first and most important is that all God has created—which is all the world (Gen. 1:1; Psalm 100:3)—belongs to him (Ps. 24:1), is for his glory (Rom. 11:36; Col. 1:16), is good (Gen. 1:31; 1 Tim. 4:4), and is entrusted to us for our joy (1 Tim. 6:17). This means we are stewards of it and are called to take care of it faithfully (Gen. 1:26-28; 2:15; Mt. 25:14-30). Certainly, regardless of what any Christian has concluded on the above issues, there is ample motivation in the Bible for us to care about this good earth God has created and entrusted to us.[6]

A second motivation found among some Christians is the long-standing accusation made against Christianity that the teachings of the Bible, especially in the call of Genesis 1:26-28 to humans to have dominion over and to subdue the earth, has led to destruction of the earth.[7] Though the reality is that any lack of concern for the environment and true destructive behavior toward it arose from those who believed man has total dominion over creation apart from any submission to God (descendants of the Enlightenment) and not from a truly consistent biblical worldview,[8] nonetheless, some Christians still feel the sting of such accusations and conclude that if we are to make a successful defense of the Christian faith we must show we are not anti-environment.

This second motivation leads to the third, namely, in our current world in which the environment plays such a huge role in the minds of so many and especially in light of accusations that deniers of climate change are much of the problem behind our current environmental crisis, there can be strong motivation to be involved and to adopt the current climate change doctrine espoused above. Some Christians might even think we have to do this in order to be taken seriously by the world around us.

Yet, what should we make of this doctrine that has concluded humans are the cause of destructive climate change that is having significant negative impact upon our planet and will only get worse if we do not radically and immediately reduce our use of carbon fuels? 

In this and four subsequent blog posts I will argue that we should be good stewards of creation, yet, we have strong reasons to doubt and to reject current climate change doctrine as just outlined. I will do this by looking at five major topics.[9]

1. An Explanation: The Earth’s Atmosphere Causes Both Warming And Cooling Influences On The Earth. 
We begin here for two reasons. First, if we are to discuss intelligently climate change, at the heart of which is global warming, we need to understand how our planet is warmed. Additionally, we must see that there are not only warming, but also cooling, influences at work. This also opens the door to a different and more complete perspective on what is currently happening on earth.

Warming Effects Of The Atmosphere
Since the warming of the earth is such a current emphasis, we will launch into our discussion by understanding how this happens.  

We are able to live on the earth because its atmosphere keeps it warm enough from the sun. The way this is done is often called “the greenhouse effect.” In other words, part of the atmosphere retains heat energy from the sun.[10]

Ninety-nine percent (78% nitrogen and 21% oxygen) of the atmosphere does not hold in the sun’s heat. There are fourteen other elements in the remaining one percent, Within these fourteen, those that don’t have a warming effect constitute 0.55% of the atmosphere. The ones that do have a warming effect constitute about 0.45% of the atmosphere and are called “greenhouse gases.”

As we zero in on the greenhouse gases we discover that water vapor makes up 80% (which is about 0.4% of the entire atmosphere—a little higher at the surface and diminishing with altitude). “The other greenhouse gases are carbon dioxide (about 0.04 % of the total atmosphere), methane (about 0.00018%), nitrous oxide (about 0.00003%), ozone (less than 0.000007%), and miscellaneous trace gases. All these other greenhouse gases (apart from water) total less than 0.05 % of the atmosphere.” It is clear, then, that water vapor is the most important greenhouse gas—“responsible for about 80% of the…warming…of the atmosphere.” Since another 15% of the warming effect derives from clouds (clouds are made of water droplets, not vapor),[11] most scientists conveniently combine water vapor and the net effect of warming clouds to say that 95% of greenhouse warming comes from water. “The remaining approximately 5% of greenhouse warming comes from carbon dioxide (about 3.6%), methane (about 0.36%), nitrous oxide (about 0.95%) and miscellaneous gases including ozone (about 0.072%).”

Unlike a greenhouse,[12] “greenhouse gases don’t keep warm air from rising and blowing away. Instead, they absorb heat energy and then radiate it outward.”[13] “Greenhouse gases absorb infrared energy (heat) [that comes from the sun to the earth’s surface] and then, having absorbed it, radiate it outward. Some of it goes up into space, thus cooling the earth by moving the heat away, but some of it radiates back down to the earth’s surface and warms the earth.”[14] It is this dual effect that keeps the earth from getting too cold or too warm. God’s wise design as seen in the “greenhouse effect” should lead us to give him thanks and praise!

Cooling Effects Of The Atmosphere
Without the greenhouse effect the earth’s temperature would average about 0 degrees Fahrenheit. With it the average temperature is about 59 degrees Fahrenheit.[15] Yet, the reason the average temperature is not higher is due to cooling influences that moderate the greenhouse effect. These influences include evaporation, precipitation, the upward movement of warm air, wind, and thousands of other feedbacks.[16] With the greenhouse effect and without such cooling influences the average temperature on earth would be 140 degrees Fahrenheit. “Since 59 degrees is about 42 percent of 140…the feedbacks considered as a whole eliminate about 58 percent of ‘greenhouse warming.’”[17]

The Controversy About Carbon Dioxide
Those who believe global warming is a threat caused by humans argue that “human activities are causing the concentration of greenhouse gases—primarily carbon dioxide, secondarily methane, and to a much lesser extent ozone and chlorofluorocarbons—to increase, and that this increased concentration could warm the earth enough to cause significant, perhaps catastrophic, harm to people and ecosystems.”[18] What contributes to this warming the most, so goes the argument, is carbon dioxide, which is responsible for about 3.6% of the total greenhouse warming effect. This carbon dioxide comes from the burning of organic material, such as wood, as well as from the burning of coal, gasoline, or natural gas (methane). As a result, much of our energy production currently releases carbon dioxide into the atmosphere.[19]

We must be quick to point out that Carbon dioxide, which is also emitted by all insects, animals, and humans (so it is a natural part of God’s creation) has many important functions. It regulates our blood flow and rate of breathing and it is crucial for photosynthesis in plants. We ought to see the following, then:
Thus, in a wonderful cycle of nature that has been designed by God, animals and people continually use up oxygen and release carbon dioxide for plants to use, and then plants use up that carbon dioxide and release oxygen for people and animals to use. Carbon dioxide is thus essential to all the major life systems on the earth. We should not think of carbon dioxide as a pollutant, but as an essential part of God’s wise arrangement of life on earth.[20]

With carbon dioxide playing such a vital role in creation, we need to ask, where do fears of climate change arise? Consider the following points:[21]
  • “Many atmospheric scientists believe the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere has risen from…about 0.028 percent to 0.040 percent, since preindustrial times (before about 1750).” 
  • The theory suggests that this increase came “from the burning of carbon-based (‘fossil’) fuels: coal, oil, and natural gas.” 
  • What is the effect of raising carbon dioxide to the degree it has been since preindustrial times? If we round the increase to doubling the amount, “according to different estimates, would raise earth’s average surface temperature, before feedbacks, by about 1.8 degrees to 2.16 degrees Fahrenheit. Frankly, that is a relatively small increase in average temperature that does not scare anybody with knowledge of climatology.” 
  • “What causes some people to fear much greater warming is the belief that climate feedback magnifies this warming.[22] So that belief is built into the computer models that predict global temperatures for many decades into the future.”
  • “All the computer models used by the United Nations’ Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) assume that climate feedbacks magnify the warming that comes from greenhouse gases.” 
It is crucial for us to stop and highlight that fears of future global warming rest on predictions of computer models. These models, which are not infallible, are dependent upon the data humans put into them and are based on giving different weights to different factors and different formulas based on different assumptions.
Therefore, the fears of future global warming rest on hypotheses represented by computer models, not on empirical observations of the real world. These models, by assuming various feedbacks that add to the greenhouse effect, predict that warming from doubled carbon dioxide since preindustrial time would result in an increase of 3.5 degrees Fahrenheit to a midrange estimate of 5.4 degrees to a high estimate of about 7 degrees over the whole period. (Global average temperature has already risen by about 1.8 degrees Fahrenheit since the Industrial Revolution, leaving about another 1.7 degree to 3.6 degrees to 5.2 degrees yet to come, of the models are right.)”[23] (emphasis added)

Those who have offered the most dire predictions and advocated for the greatest and most radical changes to our use of fossil fuels have used the larger numbers in the models. This leads to assertions that we have less than twelve years to act before climate change and its consequences are irreversible.

We must also see there is another way to project the effects. Since we know that climate feedbacks have in the past reduced the warming effects of greenhouse gases by 58 %, it is also most likely this would continue. Many scientists argue there is no justification for concluding the feedbacks will act differently with human-caused greenhouses gases than naturally-caused greenhouse gases.[24]  

What would the result be if feedbacks continue to have this effect? Earlier it was mentioned that the increase in carbon dioxide from preindustrial times would raise surface temperatures from 1.8 degree Fahrenheit to 2.16 degrees. Yet, if the feedbacks decreased these by 58%, this would mean the net effect would be a rise from 0.76 degree Fahrenheit to 0.9 degree. “An increase in average world temperature of less than 1 degree Fahrenheit is not dangerous. In fact, in general, such slight warming would be beneficial especially to agriculture…. Longer growing seasons would make food more abundant and therefore more affordable, a great benefit to the world’s poor.”[25]

Conclusion
Must we, then, believe the dire climate change predictions?  If we base our answer on actual empirical data about the effects of climate feedbacks (in other words, if we based our conclusion on observable events that have already occurred), we discover the effects of greenhouses gases are not multiplied as the computer models suggest.

Yet, there are also two other reasons to doubt the conclusions: Some biblical principles that call them into question and also other scientific evidence that lead us to doubt the dire predictions.

We will turn now to look at the principles from the Bible in our next post.


[1] The following was posted at world.wng.org on September 20, 2019.

[2] This is from an Associated Press article covering the sixth Global Environment Outlook, released March 13, 2019, at a U.N. conference in Nairobi, Kenya: “UN: Environment Is Deadly, Worsening Mess, But not Hopeless, “ Kearney Hub (March 13, 2019): 8A.

[3] Seth Borenstein (AP Science Writer), “U.N. Report Finds Humans Hammering Nature Hard,” Kearney Hub (May 6, 2019): 1A.

[4] Sahar Mansoor (Policy analyst for the Selco Foundation, which focuses on sustainable energy solutions), side bar in Mary Robinson, “Losing Ground,” The Rotarian, 197, 10 (April 2019): 39.

[5] Barry Rassin (Rotary International President), “Let’s Start The Conversation,” The Rotarian, 197, 10 (April 2019): 34. This quote is found in an interview Rassin did with The Rotarian magazine. This interview stands as the lead to a number of articles giving the sense of being non-partisan and that all are crafted to give a call to Rotarians to be part of the solution to climate change. After all, science has proven the facts of climate change and its devastating effects on the earth, animals, plants, and people (especially the poor). So, who wouldn’t want to be part of the solution? The implication of this particular quote is that hurricanes are greater in number and severity due to climate change.
The lead to the interview with Rassin reads: “The environment isn’t one of Rotary’s six areas of focus, but it’s deeply intertwined with each of them.”

[6] New Testament Scholar, Douglas J. Moo, made this very point in his article, “Nature In the New Creation: New Testament Eschatology And The Environment,” Journal Of The Evangelical Theological Society, 49 (2006): 449-88. He argues that man created in the image of God, as vice regents, who are to steward nature in God-glorifying, God-centered, and in Christ-emulating ways, along with the reality of the resurrection and the future new heaven and new earth (new creation) and its impact upon us now, all argue for us to be good stewards of the environment.
Both the document, “Climate Change: An Evangelical Call To Action” (from the Evangelical Climate Initiative) and also the document, “A Call To Truth, Prudence, And Protection Of The Poor: An Evangelical Response To Global Warming” (from the Cornwall Alliance For the Stewardship Of Creation), attest to the concern Christians of different perspectives have for the environment.

[7] This accusation was first and famously made by Lynn White, Jr., “The Historical Roots Of Our Ecological Crisis,” Science, 155 (1967): 1203-7.

[8] Moo, “Nature In The New Creation:” 13.

[9] For the direction of these blog posts and three of the five major topics I am heavily dependent upon Wayne Grudem, “Stewardship Of The Environment” (Chapter 41), in Christian Ethics: An Introduction To Biblical Moral Reasoning (Wheaton: Crossway, 2018), 1095-1169.

[10] Grudem, Christian Ethics, 1134. The following discussion about the makeup of the atmosphere also comes from this same source.

[11] Some clouds warm and some cool the earth.

[12] The greenhouse gases don’t actually function like a greenhouse.

[13] Grudem, Christian Ethics, 1135-36.

[14] Ibid, 1136.

[15] Ibid, 1136.

[16] Ibid, 1136.

[17] Ibid, 1137.

[18] Ibid, 1137.

[19] Ibid, 1137.

[20] Ibid, 1137-38.

[21] The following points come from Grudem, Christian Ethics, 1138.

[22] For an example of this way of thinking see Mary Robinson, “Losing Ground,” in the Rotarian, 197, 10 (April 2019): 36. This article was adapted from her book, written with Caitriona Palmer, Climate-Justice: Hope, Resilience, And The Fight For A Sustainable Future (Bloomsbury Publishing, 2018).

[23] Ibid, 1138-39.

[24] Ibid, 1139.

[25] Ibid, 1139.

Tuesday, April 9, 2019

Justice And Race

One of the most powerful outcomes of the Bible’s teaching on justice is the reminder that Christianity isn’t only about certain life in the world to come, it is also about living out true life now, in this world. Christians are called to help others find eternal life, but also to pursue just outcomes and make things better now (cf. Gen. 1:26-28; Eph. 2:10; Titus 2:14)!

We are called to live for a great cause, not just a great comfort, as we move toward need in this world. We do this as justice pursuers who are directed by the gospel, as gospel people who pursue the gospel’s outcome—justice!  In other words, those of us who know and follow Jesus Christ should pursue justice.

Since our series on justice has become quite long and has dealt with many subjects so far, it is helpful to revisit a definition of justice that reflects biblical teaching. We have written: “Justice identifies the moral standard by which God measures human conduct…[his own character as reflected in his moral will]…. Biblical justice, therefore, is the equitable and impartial application of the rule of God’s moral law in society…the understanding and application of God’s moral law within the social realm.”[1]

What we take up in this post is the topic of justice and race. We want to see what the Bible teaches about how to pursue “the equitable and impartial application of the rule of God’s moral law in society…the understanding and application of God’s moral law within relationships between people of different races or ethnic backgrounds.

Before going on, I will provide definitions. “Race” refers to “a distinct group of people, the members of which share certain inherited physical characteristics [such as] skin color, form of the hair, etc., and transmit them.”[2] “Ethnic” connotes that which is “of or relating to a people whose unity rests on racial, linguistic, religious or cultural ties.”[3] So, for the purposes of this post, I will use “race” or “racial” as having to do primarily with physical characteristics (such as skin color, eyes, and hair form). You can have the same or similar characteristics but be of different ethnicity. I will use “ethnic” to refer more to either current or previous cultural and linguistic ties. I will not give a lot of emphasis to distinctions between the two terms. What I am trying to address is how to pursue justice in regard to all kinds of distinctions people have: Skin color and other physical characteristics, cultural background, and even what a person’s first language might be.

I propose that if we are to pursue biblical justice in regard to race and ethnicity, there are at least six truths involved.

1. Followers Of Jesus Christ Should Pursue Justice In Regard To Race And Ethnicity. 
We need to see that the pursuit of justice in regard to race and ethnicity is not something unimportant or merely “tacked on” to Christianity by some extreme people. It is truly a worthy goal for all followers of Jesus.

I want us to see this primarily in Ephesians 2:11-22. Paul seemingly wrote this letter not so much to deal with specific problems among its readers, but to give them strong and general instruction for how their new life in Jesus Christ should impact their ethical behavior, not the least of which is their relationships with one another. The way Paul goes about this is he highlights in the first three chapters “spiritual blessing[s]” we have in Jesus Christ (cf. 1:3). Then, in the last three chapters he highlights the ethical outcomes that should emerge from all we have in Christ. So, for example, we can pursue humble oneness (4:3-4), put away all divisiveness (4:25-5:2), and love in all our different kinds of relationships (5:21-6:9) because of what Christ has done in us.

One of the amazing things that Christ has done in those of us who have been saved by grace alone through faith alone in Christ alone (2:1-10) is that he has also brought us together in Christ and given us all we need to overcome our divisions. Consider what he writes in 2:11-22:
Therefore remember that at one time you Gentiles in the flesh, called “the uncircumcision” by what is called the circumcision, which is made in the flesh by hands— 12 remember that you were at that time separated from Christ, alienated from the commonwealth of Israel and strangers to the covenants of promise, having no hope and without God in the world. 13 But now in Christ Jesus you who once were far off have been brought near by the blood of Christ. 14 For he himself is our peace, who has made us both one and has broken down in his flesh the dividing wall of hostility 15 by abolishing the law of commandments expressed in ordinances, that he might create in himself one new man in place of the two, so making peace, 16 and might reconcile us both to God in one body through the cross, thereby killing the hostility. 17 And he came and preached peace to you who were far off and peace to those who were near. 18 For through him we both have access in one Spirit to the Father. 19 So then you are no longer strangers and aliens, but you are fellow citizens with the saints and members of the household of God, 20 built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Christ Jesus himself being the cornerstone, 21 in whom the whole structure, being joined together, grows into a holy temple in the Lord. 22 In him you also are being built together into a dwelling place for God by the Spirit.

Here the specific distinction Paul has in mind is that of Jew and Gentile. In Christ both of these groups have equal access to God in Christ and so both have been made “one” (14), “fellow citizens with the saints and members of the household of God” (19), “a holy temple in the Lord” (21), and “a dwelling place for God by the Spirit” (22). Those who know Jesus Christ have all they need to live as one, to overcome differences. If this is the case for Jews and Gentiles, then it is also the case for all Gentiles (all the different kinds of races and ethnic groups in the world). In fact, we are told in Rev. 5:9 that Jesus Christ redeemed people “from every tribe and language and people and nation” and so there will be people together in heaven worshipping and serving God together “from every nation, from all tribes and peoples and languages” (Rev. 7:9), thus highlighting the power of God’s grace. God, who “made from one man every nation of mankind” (Acts 17:26) and so made us one and in harmony, is also bringing back together mankind who has been divided because of sin (e.g. Gen. 3:12, 16; 4:8). Created in the image of God to love and be in unity, that part of mankind who is being redeemed should display that the image of God in them is being restored (Eph. 4:22-24). So, we can define the church in this way: “God chooses and preserves for himself a community elected for eternal life and united by faith, who love, follow, learn from, and worship God together. God sends out this community to proclaim the gospel and prefigure Christ’s kingdom by the quality of their life together and their love for one another.”[4]

Christians of all races, ethnic distinctions, and regardless of differences are to “prefigure Christ’s kingdom by the quality of their life together and their love for one another.”

What the church is called to do, then, is to live out the power of God’s grace in us and show to the world that in Christ unity within diversity is possible. “The credibility of the gospel around the world hangs in part on this dimension of our witness.”[5]

And yet, because the church so often fails at this and has even in past times promoted racial and ethnic division, we have lacked the witness to God’s power in this area that we should have given and the world has lacked the needed model. “It is my contention that the fundamental cause of racial problems in America lies squarely with the church’s failure to come to grips with this issue from a biblical perspective…. It is the contention of this book that what has been lacking in American Christianity is the church’s failure to clearly understand and function from a kingdom perspective.”[6]

In fact, we can go as far as to ask ourselves, as John would imply in 1 John 4:7-21: “How can we truly love God when we do not truly love our brothers and sisters, even if they are different than us?”

Christians should actively pursue “biblical racial reconciliation,” which can be defined in this way: “Addressing the sin that caused the divide for the purpose of bonding together across racial lines based on a shared commitment to Jesus Christ with the goal of service to others.”[7] And yet, the reconciliation is not an end in itself. In the same way that genuine salvation is to redound to God’s glory (Eph. 1:6, 12, 14), so also the resultant new life is ultimately for God’s glory. “…the purpose of reconciliation goes further than merely being able to articulate that we are one. Reconciliation is not an end in itself. It is a means toward the greater end of bringing glory to God through seeking to advance His kingdom in a lost world.”[8]

How, then, does this purpose connect to the justice of God? As we have seen over and over, justice involves applying God’s will, righteous behavior to which he calls us, to our relations with others and to the public arena. Therefore, we agree with Tony Evans who has wisely written: “The goal of the church should be to glorify God by reflecting the values of God among the people of God through letting the truth of God be the standard by which we measure right and wrong and the way we accept skin color, class, and culture.”[9] We must remember that “…oneness is the preeminent vehicle through which God displays not only His power and His presence but also His glory.”[10]

Though all of what we have just said is true, we know that displaying unity through diversity and differences is not easy. Where do we find the strength and resources for this? We have already touched on the answer, but need to focus on it in greater detail. It is our second truth.

2. We Must Be Directed And Empowered By The Gospel In Our Pursuit of Justice in Racial and Ethnic Matters. 
In our previous point we looked at Ephesians 2:11-22, where we discover that all in Christ—Jews, Gentiles and, by implication, all kinds of Gentiles—have been given all we need to overcome division and live in unity. The larger context of Ephesians reminds us that we have been saved by grace alone through faith alone in Christ alone (2:6-9) and so we have been forgiven of our sins (1:7), redeemed (1:7), that is, recreated for good works (2:10). That recreation for good works is possible since we have the Holy Spirit to apply the person, presence, power, and work of Christ in us (1:13-14; 5:18). That larger context also tells us that what Christ has done in us (chapters 1-3) makes possible new ethical behavior, including the pursuit of unity (4:1-6), as well as the ability to love one another in the face of differences (5:1-2, 21-6:9).

There are a number of things that result from being directed and empowered by the gospel.
  • If we have been guilty of prejudice and an unwillingness to pursue racial reconciliation, we know we are forgiven in Christ (Eph. 1:7; 1 Jn. 1:7) and we can confess that sin for the restoration of fellowship with God (Eph. 4:26b-27; 1 Jn 1:9). 
  • We are assured that we have all we need to work through differences, so we can pray about this, pursue this, work toward this—all with God’s help (Eph. 4:1-6:18; James 4:8), and when we fail turn to Christ, knowing we have forgiveness (Eph. 1:7). This gives us the certainty we can keep trying and move on, rather than giving into the lies that we are not good enough, there is no use trying (Rom. 15:13; Rev. 12:11).  
  • If we are hurt as the result of racial prejudice against us (or any other prejudice or injustice), we can turn to Christ for healing and hope in our hurts (Mt. 11:28-30; Eph. 2:1-10), so we can have the strength to go on and so we can forgive (Eph. 4:29-32). 
  • If we have been made to feel inferior because of our race and/or our ethnicity, we can be encouraged and strengthened by the reality that we all have not only been created in the image of God and all races and ethnicities are important to God (Gen. 1:26-28; Ps. 8:5-6; Acts 17:26-27 [see also below]), but God has redeemed people from every race and ethnicity, made them one  in Christ, and has purposed his own glory and their benefit from this unity in diversity (Eph. 2:11-22; Rev. 5:9; 7:9). Rejoice, you are whom God made you to be and that is a good thing!
  • It has been Satan’s mode of operation from the beginning of history to lead humans to disobey God and to be divided from each other (Gen. 3-4), which is the very opposite of the God-glorifying unity that images the Trinity (Gen. 1:26-28). He continues to lead people away from righteousness (Eph. 6:14), which would include racial division, so that the church does not display God-glorifying unity. The reality of the gospel lets us know we can “be strong in the Lord and in the strength that comes from his might” (Eph. 6:10, my translation) and we can practice righteousness as a result (Eph. 6:14), which protects us from Satan’s destructive division. 
  • We will probably never pursue racial reconciliation perfectly. But we can pursue it in Christ, knowing he can forgive, heal, empower, and keep us moving forward toward it. 
  • Those who have suffered from racial prejudice can pursue justice without being hateful and vengeful (Eph. 4:29-32; James 3:13-18).
  • Being directed and empowered by the gospel also gives us the freedom to acknowledge there has been progress in both individual and structural race relations in our country, but also to acknowledge there is much still to be done-especially among the church of Jesus Christ. 
There are two ways the gospel directs and empowers us to pursue racial reconciliation that are worth highlighting by themselves. To begin, the gospel helps us to see that God has saved us to prefigure Christ’s future full kingdom during this age when the kingdom has been started. And so, we can seek first that kingdom or the agenda of the kingdom.  “The kingdom agenda is the visible manifestation of the comprehensive rule of God over very area of life…. Through the establishment of the church along with His overarching rulership above it, God has created a reflection of his kingdom in heaven on earth.”[11]

The other way the gospel directs and empowers us in the pursuit of racial reconciliation is to give us the courage and freedom to be with and to do life with those different than us. “Authentic oneness comes as an outgrowth of shared lives, not simply through a cross-cultural experience here or there…[and it] is more than tolerance…. Tolerating each other does not mean we have reconciled…. We remain relationally separated most of the time, coming together for a schedule event….”[12]

3. Pursuing Justice In Regard to Race And Ethnicity Must See That God Does Not Value One Over The Other, Nor Should We. 
“Racism is an explicit or implicit belief or practice that qualitatively distinguishes or values one race over other races.”[13]

We have already demonstrated ample evidence from the Bible to show our valuing one race over others or devaluing different races or ethnicities is wrong. It is wrong from the perspective of how God created the world, how he has saved the world, and where he is taking the world.

This is also seen in the fact that even though God’s choice of and promises to the true Israel are irrevocable (Rom. 11:28-29), the focus of God primarily on one nation and race as Israel or his people was intended to be temporary from the beginning (cf. Gal. 3:15-27). They were intended to be a light to the other nations (Is. 42:6; 49:6), to draw people to God, to prepare for the coming of Messiah, and to point to that Messiah, the true son and Israel of God (Mt. 2:13-15; Gal. 3:16). God had always intended to make people from every tribe, tongue, nation, and people group part of his people (Is. 56; Rom. 2:29; Gal. 3:28-29; Rev. 5:9; 7:9).

What is more, we see the beauty of the different races and ethnicities in the reality that the genealogy of Jesus not only displays he had people of different races, ethnicities, and genders in his ancestry, but that he himself was “mestizo—a person of mixed ancestry.”[14] “Of the five women mentioned in Matthew’s genealogy (Mt. 1:1-16), four are of Hamatic descent [and so were black]—Tamar, Rahab, Bethsheba, and Ruth.”[15] Given the reality also of his strong Jewish ancestry, this assessment is accurate.[16]

To devalue and be prejudiced against other races and ethnicities is sin and unjust behavior.

4. Pursuing Justice in Racial and Ethnic Relationships Must Address Both The Individual And The Structural Problems. 
Throughout our study on biblical justice we have focused on the four foundational relationships that people need to flourish: God, self, creation, and others. All four of these are broken because of sin and need to be redeemed. We highlighted in dealing with economics and government that when it comes to others, it is not just relationships with other individuals that needs to be addressed, but also structures or systems. The same is true when pursuing justice in racial and ethnic relationships.[17]

In Ephesians Paul shows the need to address both the individual and structural when he addresses how husbands and wives relate as a result of the gospel (5:22-32); how children and parents relate (6:1-4); and how employers and employees (6:5-9). He is not merely teaching this is a matter of personal relationships. He is also implying that views toward the very structures themselves should be transformed, and that Christians ought to go about these differently—righteously—than do their non-Christian neighbors.

Tony Evans agrees with the need to address both and words it in terms of righteousness and justice:
…at the core of the problem of racial disunity in America is the failure to understand and execute a kingdom-based theology on both righteousness and justice. A balance between the two is absolutely critical since it is from God’s kingdom throne that both righteousness and justice originate (Ps. 89:14). …White Christianity, with all its strengths, often focuses on personal righteousness at the exclusion of biblical justice. However, there exists within that scope a limited definition of personal righteousness, since the practice of biblical justice is an essential part of living a life of personal righteousness…. African-American Christianity sometimes emphasizes social justice at the expense of personal responsibility…. When either side, righteousness or justice, is missed or reduced in significance, then the individual, family, church, and society will be out of balance.”[18]

More specifically, Evans is addressing personal righteousness and public justice, but the public justice does take in structural matters.

It seems that evangelical Christians are aware of the individual aspects of racism and the need for personal responsibility. Are they aware of the structural?  “Michael O. Emerson and Christian Smith, in their book Divided By Faith: Evangelical Religion And The Problem Of Race in America, argue that, for the main part, evangelical Christians are blind to these structural dimensions of what they call the racialization of America.”[19]

I will provide three examples of what I mean by structural racism.

The first comes from history education.
Just over a year before the Liberty Bell rang out calling all to come hear the Declaration of Independence, a young Paul Revere took his well-known Midnight Ride. Few of us who have been raised under the tutelage of our country are unaware of this ride. Yet how many of us know that on the very same night, a black man, Wentworth Chesell, the freed grandson of a slave, also rode a Midnight ride? Cheswell was the first black judge elected, in 1768, a devoted husband, church member, father of thirteen children, and for forty-nine years he served our nation in some form of public office such as auditor, assessor, moderator, and “town father.”
Chewell’s commission as messenger, given him by the Committee of Safety, was the same as that given to Revere. Wentworth Cheswell rode north. Paul Revere rode west. Both had a part to play in the fight for the American Revolution. Cheswell’s alerting those in the north to make haste and organize themselves to head sought for the imminent conflict with the British served our country just as well. Yet Wentworth Cheswell is virtually nowhere to be found in our historical accounts.[20]

I don’t pretend to know certainly why Cheswell was left out of the historical accounts of our country. But I cannot help but ask could it have been due to racism that simply overlooked the contributions of blacks?  Whatever the causes of such oversights, the effect is to suggest to all that the contributions of Blacks in our country’s founding or its subsequent development and flourishing are non-existent. This can perpetuate feelings of inferiority among Blacks and also a skewed vision of Blacks by other races.

The second example comes from the evangelical church itself. Sadly evangelical churches (in some cases) and institutions (in most cases) had an equal, but separate view of Blacks until late in the civil rights movement. What this means, for example, is that some prominent churches did not allow Blacks to attend their services until late in the sixties or beyond. Additionally, many evangelical Bible colleges and seminaries did not admit Blacks into their courses of study until the same timeframe.[21] What this means, for example is that a young Martin Luther King, Jr. had no open doors to him within evangelical institutions. This was a structural racism.

This structural racism has been perpetuated in more subtle, but also significant ways in the evangelical church.
Last summer, [a major Christian publisher] distributed  a vacation Bible school curriculum called Far-out Far East Rickshaw Rally. Sadly, the content played to every stereotype imaginable about Asian culture.
The theme song headlines like, ‘Wax on was off, get your rickshaw ready’—stuff straight out of the Karate Kid. It had nothing to do with the reality of Asian culture. It showed images of little white girls in kimonos with chopsticks in their hair. Some activity suggestions are to have kids dress up in inflatable sumo outfits and wrestle each other. The stereotypes and caricatures are without shame. And this was not 1955 or 1971. It was 2004.
If you’re a socially conscious, young Asian-American, why would you ever want to step foot in a church where you would encounter people with that kind of worldview? You’ll want to stay with your own.[22]

What is exemplified here are racial and ethnic stereotypes that can perpetuate the structural injustice that certain races or ethnicities do not have equal contributions to make or are not to be taken all that seriously.

The final example comes from the area of economics and has already been alluded to when we covered that subject. It has to do with the assumption that large pour cross-sections of our society located within some races or ethnicities (e.g. Native Americans, Blacks, or Hispanics) cannot be part of the solutions to problems facing them. Instead, because they have been victimized in the past and because they simply need to be helped (implied: and can’t make progress by themselves), the solutions have: By-passed work; ignored the importance of family and faith in those solutions; encouraged fatherlessness in families; led to rampant crime, drug abuse, and alcoholism; and taken away in large measure a sense of human dignity—in many cases leaving people hopeless. Here, the structural solution is not to treat people as victims or to encourage them to view themselves as victims. It is, on the one hand, to work toward the goal that all have an opportunity to pursue success, but on the other hand, to encourage the value and dignity of earned success.

Tony Evans rightly acknowledges both the systemic causes of racism and those that arise from personal responsibility, but also highlights that some of our approaches to addressing the structural have removed a sense of personal responsibility:
While some of the challenges we face in the black community truly emanate from the past and its personal and systemic aftermath, there are also many challenges that stem from our failure to properly take responsibility for and be held accountable to our actions, morality, families, the quality of services that we provide as well as the proper management of our human and financial resources. Wrong is to be judged and changed, not applauded and excused with no consequences.
“While not seeking to diminish the impact of racism upon culture, I also want us to recognize that illegitimate or continual cries of racism are self-limiting and self-defeating. They simply foster a victim mentality that reinforces a pathology of dependency. Victimology can be defined as nurturing an unfocused strain of resentment rooted in a defeatist identity through which all realities are filtered, rather than viewing challenges as opportunities to overcome.”[23]

After addressing an over-emphasis on the systemic causes to the exclusion of the personal causes and vice versa, Evans writes: “The effect is a stronghold on both groups, that keep pockets of society chained within a prescribed framework, creating pathologies that continue and are reinforced generationally.”[24]

5. We Must Not Only Speak Of Rights But Also Responsibilities. 
One of the characteristics of Christians who are directed by Christ and the change he has brought in us is that we should love as Christ loved us and gave himself for us (Eph. 5:1-2) and so we consider the needs of others, not merely our own (Phil. 2:4). What this means is that those who have been wronged merely because of the color of their skin or their ethnicity should pursue justice in ways that are loving toward others. This means they do not hate because of the injustice and they do not justify the lack of love for others simply because they have been wronged. For they forgive and seek to respond in ways that build up, not tear down (Eph. 4:29-32).

One of the reasons this is true is because there are good works that flow from genuine saving faith (Eph. 2:10), that is, obedience of God (Rom. 1:5) and love for others (Gal. 5:6). Russian novelist and outspoken critic of the Soviet Union, Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn in the 1980’s “compared “America’s obsession with rights to a person trying to breathe with only one lung. ‘There is another lung,” says Solzhenitsyn, “and it is called duty.’  People with one lung have high mortality rates. And so it is for societies in which individuals abandon their sense of duty, refusing to deny themselves for the common good and for the sake of others….”[25] Unfortunately this self-centered view has only multiplied since then.

Tony Evans agrees and also explains the benefit that can come, even to those who have experienced racism:
Black evangelicalism emphasizes personal, family, church, and community responsibilities. Rights belong to God. Responsibilities belong to the people. These should not be lessened in light of systemic issues that make the implementation of wise life choices more difficult for many more blacks than whites in America. What the African-American community needs to understand is that while racism is a problem and a challenge that must be ultimately addressed, it is not our chief adversary. If we would seriously take responsibilities for the things we do control, then racism’s negative impact would be greatly limited, and we would flourish as a community. …We must stop excusing errant behavior in the name of racism. Even though racism was and is a major contributing factor to the decline of the black community structures, it is still our responsibility to take ownership for the things that are within our power to control. We cannot expect others to take us any more seriously than we are taking ourselves in addressing our needs.
If a Super Bowl champion team complained when they took the field that there were eleven other men on the other side of the ball trying to stop them, or if Michael Jordan had whined each time he took the court that there was always someone in his face trying to block his shot, neither would have reached the goal they had set before them. While God is a God of liberation, God is also a God who divinely used opposition as a tool that, when responded to correctly, develops perseverance, strength, determination, compassion, faith, and even, at times, greater and more personally satisfying opportunities than what would have been granted without it.
Jesus Christ does not guarantee freedom from racism, classism, sexism, or oppression while we still live in a sinful world. What He does promise is freedom from personal sin and strongholds coupled with the provision of the power to overcome…. What good is it to gain freedom from others and still be a slave to yourself?[26]

Part of the structural injustice at this point is the opposite of what many assume. We assume that since people have been mistreated due to racial or ethnic reasons that they should be entitled to be angry, to do wrong, or they should be entitled to be favored so things can be made equal. However, this not only can prove toxic to their own hearts, it also brings about several other problems:
  • It forgets God’s wisdom that justice is to be blind and is to treat all people equally in accordance with God’s righteous standards. To do anything else creates ongoing injustice.  “You shall do no injustice in court. You shall not be partial to the poor or defer to the great, but in righteousness shall you judge your neighbor.”[27] (Lev. 19:15)
  • To think we must treat a class of people differently so they can succeed (affirmative action) suggests to those persons they cannot succeed on their own and may prevent them from the joy and dignity of earned success.[28] Columnist Andree Seu Peterson, in a piece titled “Standing In Place,” World (June 30, 2018): 63, also illustrates the negative impact this can have on all involved.  
Loving your neighbor, and thus fulfilling the Great Commandment, requires the proper diagnosis. If your neighbor is hungry, give him food (James 2:15-16). If he is idle, admonish him (1 Thessalonians 5:14). If he is fainthearted, encourage him (5:14). If he is weak, help him (5:14). If he is doing good, commend him (2 Corinthians 12:11).
I rehearse these basics as a preface to discussing a four-minute viral video sent to me, which at first blush seems like love, until you question the diagnosis.
“Life of Privilege Explained in a $100 Race” will choke you up with tears. But caution: The late Canadian professor Marshall McLuhan rightly noted that the medium is not neutral; the medium itself plays a role in the message and shapes the message in subtle and powerful ways. Everything about this short production is calculated for a particular effect. This is not a controversial observation: Why else would the creator create if not to produce a desired effect?
At first blush the video’s message seems like love, until you question the diagnosis.
The morning after, if your abiding desire is to think Biblically and to “test the spirits” (1 John 4:1), you will ask yourself if the video has the proper diagnosis on two fronts: First, does it analyze the problem correctly? Second, does its widespread dissemination tend to heal or tend to exacerbate our nation’s societal problems?
The setting is a college foot race, in which students are lined up and offered a $100 bill to the winner. But before the signal to go, the instructor reveals that this race will proceed according to specific instructions, which he now begins to announce: “Take two steps forward if both your parents are still married.” (A winnowing begins, as a handful of students, notably dark-skinned ones, stay put.) “Take two steps forward if you grew up with a father figure at home.” (More fragmenting of the line after some take giant steps and others, mostly black, don’t budge.) “Take two steps forward if you never had to worry about your cell phone being turned off.” You get the drift.
At this point the instructor tells the white kids at the head of the group to turn around and look back at the starting line. He begins lecturing them: “Every statement I’ve made has nothing to do with anything any of you have done. … We all know these people up here have a better opportunity to win this hundred dollars. Does this mean these people back here can’t race? No. We would be foolish not to realize we’ve been given more opportunity. We don’t want to recognize that we’ve been given a head start. But the reality is we have. … Whoever wins this hundred dollars, I think it would be extremely foolish of you not to utilize that in learning more about somebody else’s story. Because the reality is, if this was a fair race … I guarantee you some of these black dudes would smoke all of you. And it’s only because you have this big head start that you’re possibly going to win this race called life. Nothing you’ve done has put you in the lead.”
But who is this man to say to any student that “nothing you’ve done has put you in the lead”? And who is he to judge anyone’s heart and assert, “We don’t want to recognize that we’ve been given a head start”? And what kind of divisive racism is it to say that some of the black students would “smoke all of you [white students]” if it were a fair race?
So the white students are made to feel guilty and ashamed. And the black students are made to feel forever the victim who cannot possibly be expected to do anything. And how, pray tell, does this love anybody well?
One commenter posts: “Take two steps forward if you grew up in a two-parent household. Take two steps backward if your parents fought every night. Take two steps forward if your father didn’t abandon you. Take two steps backward if he set forth unreasonable, unattainable, and demoralizing expectations.” Everyone has obstacles.
What I personally take from the video is that if you want your kids to flourish, work hard, save childbearing for marriage, and stay married.
Whether you’re black, white, or green.

  • Such a way of thinking can create a mentality of victimization, which can hurt all involved. “While not seeking to diminish the impact of racism upon culture, I also want us to recognize that illegitimate or continual cries of racism are self-limiting and self-defeating. They simply foster a victim mentality that reinforces a pathology of dependency. Victimology can be defined as nurturing an unfocused strain of resentment rooted in a defeatist identity through which all realities are filtered, rather than viewing challenges as opportunities to overcome.”[29]
Jesus taught that righteous (Mt. 5:6; 6:33) and loving (Mt. 5:43-47) action toward others includes treating them as we would desire to be treated (Mt. 7:12). We all have experienced ways parents, coaches, or mentors have called us to do hard things for our good and so we could flourish, hard things that we may have not enjoyed at first. If we have not been the recipients of racial prejudice, yet we are seeking to love those who have, love them in the ultimate way—by praying for them and encouraging them to the best possible life. This is one in which they are forgiving, loving, and pursuing justice apart from bitterness. Such is an important part of a righteous and just life.

6. We Must Teach The Next Generation Of Believers How To Pursue Justice in Racial and Ethnic Matters. 
In each of the topics we are looking at in this justice study we are highlighting the importance of teaching the next generation. This is important not only because we are called to teach and disciple the next generation of believers, which includes children and grandchildren (Dt. 6:4-9; Prov. 22:6; Mt. 28;19-20; Eph. 6:4), we also know that when the next generation is not taught and guided in areas of justice, it is easy for them to be misdirected by false views of justice (Eph. 4:14).

In regard to racial and ethnic issues, this teaching can include at least the following:
  • The five truths we have set forth in our discussion about race and ethnicity.
  • We need to teach our children and the next generation of believers about racism and its history in our country and why a Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. would be killed. We might read to them or tell them about the “Letter From A Birmingham Jail” by Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. King—giving perspective on whether or not the African American should act or just be passive.[30]
  • We should teach the contributions that people of color have made to both our country and to the church. One example we mentioned above when telling the story of Wentworth Cheswell, the fellow midnight rider with Paul Revere. We could tell also about James Armistead, another black man who, 
…at great personal risk, …posed as a runaway slave and pretended to be a British spy, all the while gaining the confidence of General Benedict Arnold and General Charles Cornwallis…. Armistead’s reports documented the movements of the British, giving General [George] Washington all that he needed to bring about a swift end to the war, saving scores of American lives not only in Yorktown, but in future battles that did not have to be fought.[31]

Conclusion
In his Introduction (“William Wilberforce: The Importance Of Doctrine And ‘Coronary’ Commitment”) to Part Two (“God’s Word: The Power Of The Gospel”) in Bloodlines John Piper writes:
One of the ways I think about the aim of this book, and the aim of my ministry, is that I labor to multiply a certain kind of person—persons who are committed to live for a great biblical cause, not a great earthly comfort. Over the years I have tried to wave this banner: to be a Christian is to move toward need, not comfort. Christian life means to get up in the morning and go to bed at night dreaming not about how to advance my comforts but how to advance some great God-centered cause.

 This has been the overarching aim of our study on justice. May it become the overarching aim of our life as we pursue justice together—including racial and ethnic matters.

Joyfully Pursuing Justice With You,

Tom

[1] All but the bracketed clause and the last clause of this definition is taken from Tony Evans, Oneness Embraced: Reconciliation, The Kingdom, And How We Are Stronger Together (Chicago: Moody, 2011), 260.
[2] The New Lexicon Webster’s Dictionary of The English Language (New York, Lexicon Publications, Inc., 1989), 822.
[3] Ibid., 324.
Steven C. Hawthorne, “Mandate on the Mountain,” in Ralph D. Winter, Steven C. Hawthorne, Ed’s., Perspectives On The World Christian Movement: A Reader (Pasadena, Ca.: William Carey Library, 2009, 4th ed.), 128, defines the word ethnos (which stands behind ethnic) as peoples groups and then says: “Linguistic, cultural, social, economic, geographic, religious, and political factors can each be part of what gives formation to the peoples of the earth.”
[4] The New City Catechism #48. See Mt. 5:16; 6:33; John 13:34-35; 17:21-23; Phil. 2:14-15; 2 Thes. 2:13; 2 Tim. 2:10 for confirmation.
[5] John Piper, Bloodlines: Race, Cross, And The Christian (Wheaton: Crossway, 2011, Kindle version), ch. 2.
[6]Tony Evans, Oneness Embraced: Reconciliation, The Kingdom, And How We Are Stronger Together (Chicago: Moody, 2011), 18. 
[7] Evans, Oneness, 32.
[8] Evans, Oneness, 19.
[9] Evans, Oneness, 27.
[10] Evans, Oneness, 33. Thabiti Anyabwile, “The Supremacy Of Christ In Ethnic Distinctions And Identities,” in Sam Storms, Justin Taylor, Eds, For The Fame Of God’s Name: Essays In Honor Of John Piper (Wheaton: Crossway, 2010), 299f, brings to light that it is not only that God created all diversity in the beginning, but also that he has redeemed people from every tribe, tongue, nation, and people group who will worship him together for all eternity that will glorify him. Given these two book ends of history and God’s purpose, we also should pursue God’s glory in oneness now! He adds (300): “The church, then, becomes a foretaste of that consummated age to come when the nations, assembled around the throne of God, praise the Lamb in eternal song…. This is the end for which the nations are made: to glorify God as one new people through faith and union in his Son. The ethnic and language distinctions remain, but there comes into view an overarching unity in praise and worship of the sovereign redeeming God and Lamb.” He goes on (301ff.) to write: “The supremacy of Jesus Christ over ethnic identities may be seen in several ways. First, God assigns to all individuals their particular nation with the aim that they might by that very appointment come to find him…Acs 17:26-27…. Second, the cross-work of Christ creates a new spiritual ethnicity, a new man, which ends our hostilities and alienation…Eph. 2:13-16…. Third, the new spiritual ethnicity created in Christ makes natural ethnic identities secondary…Gal. 3:27-28…1 Cor. 12:13…. Fourth,…in Christ we are being renewed to the image of God—not made a more pristine ethnic person…2 Cor. 3:18…Col. 1:15…Col. 3:10…Eph. 4:22, 24….”
Finally, Anyabwile (305-6) highlights that the way forward in race relations is not to downplay or dummy down doctrine. Instead, it is to be theologically precise.
[11] Evans, Oneness, 44. Evans also adds (106): “It is my uncompromising contention that the only proper perspective is the divine perspective; the only proper agenda is the kingdom agenda.”
[12] Evans, Oneness, 23.
[13] Piper, “A Note To The Reader on Race And Racism,” in Bloodlines.
[14] Evans, Oneness, 121.
[15] Evans, Oneness, 121.
[16] Both Piper, Appendix Four, in Bloodlines, and Evans, Oneness, 92ff., dispel the thinking that the so-called “curse of Ham,” i.e. the curse upon Canaan, a descendant of Ham, the son of Noah who witnessed Noah’s nakedness (Gen. 9:22-27) led to black people being cursed. At least two things need to be said: The curse was not upon Ham, but upon Canaan and so it could not be upon black people. The curse is not irrevocable, as if such descendants would always be cursed, have no hope of salvation, and/or would be considered inferior in the eyes of God.
[17] Piper, Bloodlines, in ch. 5 (“Personal Responsibility And Systemic Intervention”),  calls attention to both the place of personal responsibility and also systemic causation and that both need to be addressed in alleviation. The presence of brokenness in both are results of sin.
[18] Evans, Oneness, 22.
[19] Piper, Bloodlines. 
[20] Evans, Oneness, 35.
[21] See Evans, Oneness, 186-88, 234-35.
[22] Piper, Bloodlines, ch. 2. This quote is from a 2005 interview with Soong-Chan Rah, a senior pastor of Cambridge Community Fellowship Church in Massachusetts.
[23] Evans, Oneness, 21-22.
[24] Evans, Oneness, 34.
[25] Charles Colson, The God Of Stones And Spiders: Letters To A Church In Exile (Wheaton: Crossway, 1990), 22.
[26] Evans, Oneness, 213-14.
[27] Herein is the origin of the idea that justice is to be “blind.” It is not to favor one person over the other in decisions about what is right and wrong. We might add we should not favor one person over the other in regard to the opportunities to flourish. It is to deal with people (as does God, which is why righteousness is mentioned here) in ways that genuinely measure up to and fit with what they have done. In other words, justice is dispensing what is due that measures up to and fits both with love for God and people, and with what is true. At the same time we remember love for God and people will not overlook the dispensing of penalties and discipline (e.g. Prov. 3:11-12).
[28] Piper, Bloodlines, ch. 5.
[29] Evans, Oneness, 21-22.
[30] Piper, Bloodlines, Introduction.
[31] Evans, Oneness, 35-36.
He also writes (36): “Similarly, the contributions of the black church have often been neglected or marginalized.”
In Part 2 of the book Evans looks at black history, the history of black evangelicalism, and dispels the myth of black inferiority.  Chapter 6 covers “The Black Presence In The Bible;” chapter 9 “The Role Of The Black Preacher;” chapter 10 “The Black Church, Black Power, And Black Theology” (where he covers the reality that conservative Bible schools and seminaries excluded blacks—being very slow to change in this!); and  chapter 11 “The Rise Of Black Evangelicalism.”