Monday, September 3, 2018

Justice And Economics, Part 1

When I was growing up and a young adult it was very rare to hear someone say they preferred socialism or communism to capitalism.[1] Certainly there were arguments in favor of the slightly less extreme socialism in universities,[2] but the images from countries such as the USSR, China, and Cuba, for example, were simply too negative for the theories to go main stream. Recently this has changed drastically, especially among younger adults, as evidence by the following:
·         The rise and popularity of socialist Bernie Sanders during the 2016 presidential primary.

·         The victory of Democrat Socialist Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez of New York in that state’s 2018 Democrat primary.

·         In Omaha the upset of Brad Ashford in the 2018 Democrat primary by Sanders backer and socialist, Kare Eastman.[3]

·         “Millennials (sometimes defined as those born between 1977 and 1996) are going politically left rather than right by an almost 4-1 margin.”[4]

·         “One poll showed half of American millennials saying they prefer socialism to capitalism.”

·         “Membership in the imaginatively named Democratic Socialists of America has grown sevenfold since the 2016 election. The number of chapters has almost quintupled.”

We can most likely pinpoint several factors for this shift. On the one hand, the world has become a much smaller place because of technology in general and social media in particular. This has removed some of the “alien” feel associated with centralized forms of government. Additionally, many younger adults have rubbed shoulders with far more people from socialist or communist countries as more and more international students have come to the United States. And, of course, the former USSR and Soviet block no longer exist, China has been significantly impacted by western and capitalistic influence (even though it remains officially communist), and most U.S. media outlets have become less and less suspicious of centralized governments and economic systems.

At the same time that all this has been happening, the United States, through the influence of government leaders, has creeped little by little toward a more centralized or socialist structure. For younger adults, especially, all they have known is the presence of a growing number of government programs and apologists for such programs as being compassionate in their help of the poor.

What this changing environment has made possible is for millennials and even younger adults to advocate for socialist principles, even if some may not apply the label. Of course, as the label “socialism” is used more and more positively more are willing to wear the label.

One of the effects this shift in thinking has had is to lead many young Christian adults who are advocates of social justice to prefer socialism, to be favorable toward it, or at least not to oppose it. At the very least, so the thinking goes, if gospel work and making disciples is our main work and we are not to be held hostage by partisan political theories, and if the Bible really doesn’t have that much to say about how we should approach government and what our view of economics should be, then really it doesn’t matter what your position is on this entire subject.[5] In fact, some might argue, “Isn’t socialism more compassionate than capitalism anyway, and so it ought to be preferred by Christians? After all, at least with socialism you can be seen as compassionate and not a stingy capitalist.”[6]

It is this very thinking that I want to push back on in this post. I am not doing this because I think partisan political posturing is more important than God’s Word. Nor am I doing it since I am “in the back pocket of a political party” or because I merely want to keep the things “the way they have always been.” What I want us to discover is that though a person can hold to socialist view of economics and government and still be a Christian, that person cannot hold to a socialist view and, at the same time, have a view of economics and government that is consistent with the Bible!

That statement may seem to be extreme to the eyes of many Christians in our current culture, but I hope to demonstrate it is true in this and my next two posts.

Before getting into the particulars, I want to remind us why this subject has arisen. We are in the midst of a series of blog posts looking at how to pursue biblical justice and to do so as truly compassionate Christians, seeking the well-being of others in regard to a number of hot and debated topics in our society. Economics is one of those. To put this another way, if we do not look at this subject in light of biblical wisdom, the very wisdom of the God who created this world and us to function as he did and knows how we best function, we will likely contribute to the hurt and pain that bad economic and government approaches bring upon fellow citizens. This would be the opposite of love and justice.

So, to show that the Christian who loves his neighbor in the biblical sense ought to advocate a biblical view of government and economics and what that view is, we will set forth the following seven truths from the Bible.

1. God Created Humans With Four Key Relationships That Must Be Kept In Mind As We Shape Our Governmental and Economic Approach. 
The biblical worldview reminds us that to see poverty as merely the lack of material resources or to see human flourishing as merely the acquisition of material resources, as most North Americans do, is short-sided. We will see this in what the Bible teaches, but it is also evidenced in how those who experience the poverty of resources speak of their situation. Though they do not discount the material lack, they also “tend to describe their condition in far more psychological and social terms…. Poor people typically talk in terms of shame, inferiority, powerlessness, humiliation, fear, hopelessness, depression, social isolation, and voicelessness.”[7]

One of the effects that seeing poverty only as lack of material resources has had is to blind us to more full-orbed approaches to problems. For over fifty years the war on poverty fought in the United States has committed over twenty trillion dollars to alleviating poverty, with little results other than making people slightly more comfortable in their poverty.[8] And, at the same time, we have fostered an “end-justifies-the-means” approach among some citizens who believe that they lack equality in material resources. Since what we have or do not have materially is the main or only thing, they conclude it really doesn’t matter how this is addressed, as long as we change the material state of the poor or disadvantaged.

To correct this, what we must do is to go back and gain a fuller vision of who human beings are and the four key relationships humans have. To ignore these is to possess a view of humans that is distorted and will only hurt. 

“Due to the comprehensive nature of the fall, every human being is poor in the sense of not experiencing these four relationships in the way that God intended…. For some people the brokenness in these foundational relationships results in material poverty, that is, their not having sufficient money to provide for the basic physical needs of themselves and their families.”[11]

We will look more closely at each relationship.

A. Relationship With God 
The Bible makes it clear that humans were created in the image of God, to resemble him and reflect his glory as his vice-regents, bringing order throughout the world (Gen. 1:26-28; Ps. 8:5-6). Such a creation mandate could only happen in humble dependence upon God and in close fellowship with him (Gen. 2:16-17; 3:8). God is the one who must give true and full life, to animate humans to carry out the purposes for which they were created (Gen. 2:7) and the one who must direct the best way for them to live (Gen. 2:16-17). And, in fact, apart from dependence upon and listening to God we find only brokenness, pain, and suffering—as evidenced in the disobedience of our first parents, Adam and Eve, and its results (Gen. 3:1-24).

The rest of the Bible is clear that God directs mankind in how to come to know and follow him and does it both for his glory and our good. In Deuteronomy 10:12-13 we read: “And now, Israel, what does the Lord your God require of you, but to fear the Lord your God, to walk in all his ways, to love him, to serve the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul, and to keep the commandments and statutes of the Lord, which I am commanding you today for your good?”  In John 10:10 we learn of one of the reasons Jesus Christ came into the world to accomplish salvation and reconcile man to God: “I came that they may have life and have it abundantly.”

It is also important for us to understand that seeking to figure out life apart from God does not bring good results. Proverbs 14:12 shares this wisdom: “There is a way that seems right to a man, but its end is the way to death.” More specifically, Jesus affirms that apart from being united to him through faith, humans cannot carry out the purposes for which we were created, nor realize God-honoring results (John 15:5).

Because sin has entered the world through Adam (Rom. 5:12) and all are born in sin, as those who are spiritually dead and cannot function as God intended (Eph. 2:1-3), this most important of all relationships is broken. Unless this most basic kind of poverty is addressed (Jesus says in Mt. 5:3 the most fundamental realization we must come to if we are to be part of the kingdom is that we are spiritually poor), we will be assured of hurting those we are attempting to help, as well as hurting self (the helpers).

In light of this basic truth that we were made to have relationship with God and yet that relationship has been broken through sin, “until we embrace our mutual brokenness, our work with low-income people is likely to do far more harm than good.”  This is due to the reality that as sinful people, the economically rich who get involved in helping the poor often have “god-complexes,” i.e. “a subtle and unconscious sense of superiority in which they believe that they have achieved their wealth through [only] their own efforts and that they have been anointed to decide what is best for low-income people, whom they view as inferior to themselves.”[12]  And so, “one of the biggest problems in many poverty-alleviation efforts is that their design and implementation exacerbates the poverty of being of the economically rich—their god-complexes—and the poverty of being of the economically poor—their feelings of inferiority and shame.”[13] At the same time, if we ignore this relationships, we fail to address the most basic poverty or need a person has, that of a lack of relationship with the Creator and Redeemer.

B. Relationship With Self
We can infer from the Bible that God created humans to be content in him, as well as with the resources and circumstances he ordained for them (cf. Gen. 2:16-17). This would reflect a peace or wholeness within self that is lost due to our sin and must be restored through the work of God’s Spirit in the regenerate (Gal. 5:22; Phil. 4:11).

When this basic relationship is not addressed, it, along with the first broken relationship (the one with God), lays the foundation for humans not to see their need for God or even to desire to know, love, worship, and serve God (Rom. 3:10-12; 1 Cor. 2:14). It leads to a brokenness of soul and restlessness (Is. 61:1) that leads away from joy (Prov. 17:22; Gal. 5:22).

This can lead the materially wealthy to lack contentment no matter how much they have, to think they must always have more, and to become enslaved to those desires—and to think others should as well. This can distort approaches to poverty alleviation. At the same time, it leads those who have a lack of material resources to blame others and to be angry toward others for their situation, and so to approach fixing their situation in ways that are destructive.

The brokenness and sinfulness inherent in regard to these first two relationships exacerbate the remaining two.

C. Relationship With Creation 
In Genesis 1:26-28 we read not only that God made humans in his image, but also what this means for our relationship to creation: 
Let us make man in our image, after our likeness. And let them have dominion over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the heavens and over the livestock and over all the earth and over every creeping thing that creeps on the earth.” So God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them. And God blessed them. And God said to them, “Be fruitful and multiply and fill the earth and subdue it, and have dominion over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the heavens and over every living thing that moves on the earth.

The verbs that describe the activity of humans (“have dominion over” “be fruitful,” “multiply,” “fill the earth,” subdue it”) not only show the mission for which God created us—a mission in which we resemble and reflect him to his glory (Ps. 8:5-6), but they also convey the activity of vice regents. Like the one in whose image humans are created, we are to work, create, and bring order to the world. Genesis 2:15 (“The Lord God took the man and put him in the garden of Eden to work it and keep it.”) highlights further that mankind was created to be workers. When we put this together with Psalm 8:5-6, we understand that work is part of the way people glorify God and it is part of the dignity of humans.

It is in light of this foundational teaching we come to see in the Bible that: 
·         It is God’s moral will for humans to work (Exodus 20:9: “Six days you shall labor and do your work.”) and typically he provides for the needs of humans through work (Prov. 10:4-6; 13:4).

·         God has created the world and humans in such a way that they function best when they are motivated by their needs and those of family to work and to produce (Prov. 6:6-11; 16:26; 21:25; 31:15-18).

·         The work of humans is good because of the way it honors God (Ps. 8:5-6), serves others (Prov. 31:15-24), and brings order to the world (Gen. 1:26-28). This is why we can say that, “A primary work of the church is the church at work.”[14]

·         Working to provide for one’s own needs and also that of their family is characteristic of what one does who believes in and follows God (Eph. 4:28; 1 Tim. 5:8) and so if a person is able to work and unwilling, others are not to give him provision and thus encourage him not to work (2 Thes. 3:10).

·         When people face poverty of resources and/or opportunity, part of preserving their dignity, honoring God and the way he has created us, and also in light of how they will best flourish, it is to be realized they must be part of figuring out the solution (Gen. 1:26-28). This will not only help them flourish, but this earned success also will give them far more satisfaction (Prov. 12:11, 24; 14:23; 22:29; 31:18). What is more, if it is appropriate and genuinely helpful to provide resources to others in a time of need (a safety net), it is best if those receiving the resources work to receive them (Lev. 19:9-10).

·         It is God’s moral will for humans to be generous and to help those who experience a poverty of resources, and not to be greedy (Prov. 14:21, 31; 19:17; 22:29; 31:20). Though this is true, this does not negate the truth that work, business, profit, and the creation of wealth are all good things (Prov. 21:5; 31:18; Eph. 4:28). They are part of the best and most ultimate solutions for material poverty.

What we discover, then, is that for Christians who are genuinely pursuing righteousness and justice, this must include encouraging responsibility, hard work, problem-solving, and the reality that work, productivity, business formation, and wealth creation are all very good things that glorify God and benefit people. To advocate for approaches to poverty alleviation that do not keep these things in mind, but instead by-pass work and demonize business are unjust, unbiblical approaches.

To take this a step further, to advocate for these principles in our approach to economics in general and to the alleviation of poverty in particular is not a matter of being left, right, Democrat, or Republican. This is not about “being in the pocket” of one side or the other. It is instead about pursuing true justice and also holding to approaches and solutions that work and benefit others.

To grasp, advocate for, and to practice these principles is also important because sin leads to great brokenness in this area. Greed, deceit, and injustice on the part of employers (James 5:1-6), deceit, injustice, and laziness on the part of employees (Prov. 10:26; Eph. 6:5-8), hopelessness and shame for those in poverty, arrogance on the part of those with material resources who may help in ways that hurt, and the overall tendency in our society to think business and wealth are innately evil all are results of sin and ultimately hurt those who experience resource poverty. As we have already discovered, “One of the biggest problems in many poverty-alleviation efforts is that their design and implementation exacerbate the poverty of being of the economically rich—their god-complex- es—and the poverty of being of the economically poor—their feelings of inferiority and shame.”[15]

D. Relationship With Others
When God created man he said, “It is not good that the man should be alone; I will make him a helper fit for him” (Gen. 2:18). As a result, God created woman and they were in perfect unity and lacked shame in their relationship prior to sin (Gen. 2:21-25). They also were intended to work together to bring order into the world (Gen. 1:26-28). Once sin entered the world humans were full of shame (Gen. 3:7), fear (Gen. 3:8-10), blaming each other (3:12), as well as hatred and jealousy (Gen. 3:16; 4:1-8).

Jesus affirmed that the relationship with God was ultimately foundational, but that how we relate to others flows out of our relationship with God and itself is foundational (Mt. 22:37-40).

We should not be surprised, then, that a very destructive poverty that is growing and wreaking great havoc in people is the poverty of relationship with others. Arthur Brooks explains:
Today, the poorest 20 percent of American adults are only a fifth as likely to be married as the richest 20 percent. They are about 30 percent more likely to say they never attend religious services and over 60 percent more likely to say they never spend time with neighbors. They also work, on average about 20 percent fewer hours per week. These patterns are decidedly not concentrated in any racial or ethnic group…they afflict all sorts of economically vulnerable Americans.[16]

If we look closely at what Brooks is saying we discover that at least three of the four relationships that are foundational to humans (God, creation, and other people) are broken and/or non-existent in the lives of many who are struggling and not flourishing.

Wendy Wang and and W. Bradford Wilcox of the Institute for Family Studies confirmed these conclusions when they recently reported their findings of a lengthy study that was cosponsored by the American Enterprise Institute. 
[The study] examines a group of Millennials whom the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth has been following since 1997, and who were last interviewed in 2013 and 2014, when they were 28 to 34 years old. The report finds that the link between marriage and economic success among Millennials is “robust after controlling for a range of background factors.” Compared with the path of having a baby first, marrying before children more than doubles young adults’ odds of being in the middle or top income tier….[17]

Additionally, Wang and Wilcox report that “the economic welfare of millenials (i.e., more likely to reach the middle class and to avoid poverty) is significantly affected by their following a set of norms that have been called the ‘success sequence’:”
1. Graduate from high school; 
2. Maintain a full-time job or have a partner who does; and 
3. Have children while married, should they choose to become parents.[18]

Wang and Wilcox confirm the findings of other studies through the last three decades that speak of the importance of not having children until a person is married, the benefit of getting married and staying married, the benefit of having employment and staying employed, and the benefit of faith for people to flourish and to avoid the poverty of resources.

One factor that is often added in other studies is staying out of legal trouble. Yet, the evidence for many years is that contrary to what many argue, crime is not first and foremost a result of environmental factors. It is a most often due to the lack of moral training in the formative years. Two decades ago Chuck Colson penned words that are still just as true today: 
In 1977, psychologist Stanton Samenow and psychiatrist Samuel Yochelson published a landmark seventeen-year study, The Criminal Personality. They found that crime cannot be traced primarily to environmental factors. The only adequate explanation, they concluded, is the moral choices of individuals. The solution to crime, they said (revealing their Jewish roots), is “the conversion of the wrongdoer to a more responsible lifestyle.”
In 1987 professors Richard J. Herrnstein and James Q. Wilson came to similar conclusions in Crime and Human Nature. They determined that the cause of crime is a lack of moral training in the morally formative years.[19]

A 2014 American Academy of Sciences report found not only an unprecedented growing incarceration rate over the past forty years in the United States, but also a staggering impact this has on families, especially through the absence of fathers in the home—a reality that leads to greater levels of behavior problems and delinquency among children and youth. This often leads to a cycle of crime, as well as poverty of resources.[20]

What we see over and over is that all four of the relationships we are focusing on matter when it comes to poverty and that this certainly includes relationships with others. Family matters. Dads in the home matter. Marriage matters. How we treat others matters. “Poverty is the result of relationships that do not work, that are not just, that are not for life, that are not harmonious or enjoyable. Poverty is the absence of shalom [or peace] in all its meanings.”[21]

Conclusion 
The key point for our current discussion is that if we are pursuing genuine and real justice, we must keep in mind these four relationships and the resultant broken systems that arise from them. We cannot simply address the symptom of a poverty of resources.

This first truth gives shape to the remaining six truths we will look at in our next two blog posts.

Joyfully Pursuing Justice With You,

Tom

[1] Merriam-Webster (on-line) defines capitalism this way: “An economic system characterized by private or corporate ownership of capital goods, by investments that are determined by private decision, and by prices, production, and the distribution of goods that are determined mainly by competition in a free market.” Merriam-Webster (on-line) defines “capital” in this manner: “relating to or being assets that add to the long-term net worth of a corporation [such as] capital improvements.” Michael Novak, in Joel Belz, “System For Sinners,” World (March 18, 2017): 4, writes: “Socialism is a system for saints. Democratic capitalism works because it’s a system for sinners.” Again: “Novak has always preferred the term ‘democratic capitalism,’ arguing repeatedly that a purely capitalistic system, with no restraints, is almost certain—because of the sinfulness of humans—to produce unacceptably ugly results.”
Merriam-Webster (on-line) defines socialism this way: “Any of various economic and political theories advocating collective or governmental ownership and administration of the means of production and distribution of goods.” The same source defines communism as follows: “A system in which goods are owned in common and are available to all as needed; a theory advocating elimination of private property.” 

[2] As early as the 1940’s F. A Hayek, in his book The Road To Serfdom, was sounding the warning that gatekeepers in the west were advocating centralized forms of government.

[3] This and the following bullet points are taken from from Marvin Olasky, “Between Anywhere and Somewhere: An afternoon with U.S. Sen. Ben Sasse,” in World (July 21, 2018).

[4] This is not an inordinately partisan statement, as if made by one who is beholden to or “in the back pocket” of conservative and/or Republican political thought. To be left leaning includes that these younger adults also lean toward socialist economic and governmental theories—centralized government, big government, and turning to the government first and foremost for solutions, rather than the private sector. It also suggests that these younger adults lean in the direction of believing social justice involves the redistribution of wealth and the equalizing not just of opportunities, but also of outcomes. 

[5] Merriam-Webster (on-line) defines “economics” in this way: “A social science concerned chiefly with description and analysis of the production, distribution, and consumption of goods and services. I would take this a step further: Economics deals with how we can approach the production, distribution, and consumption of goods and services in a manner that is best for those in a particular society, such as the United States. To argue, as I will below, that we must have a biblical view of economics means that we must consider at least what the Bible teaches about who people are, what our relationship to work and production ought to be, how provision for human needs is best carried out, how a government ought to relate to such an economic view, and what does the Bible teach about poverty alleviation. 

[6] It is now true that growing up in the United States means you are inundated with centralized government, wealth redistribution, and equality of finish line thinking in all levels of education, through major media outlets, and in the warp and woof of the culture itself. Anything else now appears to lack compassion. 

[7] Steve Corbett, Brian Fikkert, When Helping Hurts: How To Alleviate Poverty Without Hurting The Poor…and Yourself (Chicago: Moody, 2012, repr.), 51.

[8] Arthur C. Brooks, The Conservative Heart: How To Build A Fairer, Happier, And More Prosperous America (New York: Harper Collins, 2015),  2-3. See also Timothy S. Goeglein, “The Moynihan Report At 50,” in The City, 8, 2 (Winter 2015): 7-12. 

[9] This is taken from Corbett, Fikkert, When Helping, 56.

[10] Corbett, Fikkert, When Helping, 56.

[11] Corbett, Fikkert, When Helping, 59-60.


[12] Corbett, Fikkert, When Helping, 61.


[13] Corbett, Fikkert, When Helping, 62.

[14] Tom Nelson, Work Matters: Connecting Sunday Worship To Monday Work, 190. 

[15] Corbett, Fikkert, When Helping, 62.

[16] Arthur C. Brooks, The Conservative Heart: How To Build A Fairer, Happier, And More Prosperous America (New York: Harper Collins, 2015), 53-54.

[17] Joe Carter, “How Millennials Can Avoid Poverty: Follow The ‘Success Sequence,’” a July 18, 2017 blog post, accessed September 3, 2018, at thegospelcoalition.org.

[18] Carter, “How Millennials.” 

[19] Chuck Colson, “Crime And The Cure Of The Soul,” First Things (October 1993), accessed September 3, 2018 at firstthings.com.

[20] See Eric Metaxas, “For Such A Time As This: Restoring Prisoners And Their Families,” a June 16, 2014 blog post, accessed September 3, 2018, at breakpoint.org.

[21] Corbett, Fikkert, When Helping, 59.


Thursday, August 30, 2018

Justice And The Sanctity Of Life, Part 2

In our previous post we began looking at justice and the sanctity of human life, focusing in primarily on the topic of abortion. We said that we must deal with two problems in regard to abortion. We have already dealt with the first: The reputation that Christians are partisan in regard to and unduly focused upon abortion.

Now, in this post we take up the second problem.

2. Problem Two: What The Bible Really Teaches. 
This second problem deals with the idea there are two competing ethical issues involved in abortion. On the one hand, there is the idea that government’s role in the lives of its citizens should be limited and should not remove their freedom to make choices. In other words, the government should not tell a woman what she must do with her own body. On the other hand, there is the issue of the sanctity of life. How do we reconcile these two important matters?

Let’s look at each in turn.

A. Freedom Of Choice.
It is true that the Bible values people making choices: “I have set before you today life and good, death and evil. If you obey…then you shall live and multiply…. But if your heart turns away…you shall surely perish…” (Dt. 30:15-18); “Choose this day whom you will serve” (Josh. 24:15). It also affirms it is better for people to make choices when they really want to do them as opposed to being coerced into them (Philemon 14). The Bible also gives reasons for citizens to prefer governments that are limited in power and scope, rather than being ever-present to have its hand in every decision that is made (cf. Deut. 17:14-20; Rom. 13:1-7; Rev. 13:1-18).

So, we can conclude that it is right that the government should not force citizens to do what it desires against their will in every case and it should not be involved in every area of life. Yet, does this mean that it is wrong for the government to enact laws that protect life in the womb and prohibit abortion? 

The answer is, “No,” for two reasons.

The first reason is that some biblical principles have greater weight than others. Matthew 23:23 reads: “Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! For you tithe mint and dill and cumin, and have neglected the weightier matters of the law: justice and mercy and faithfulness. These you ought to have done, without neglecting the others.” It is important to tithe says Jesus, but even more important is expressing justice, mercy, and faithfulness toward others.

The principle applies to the preservation of life. We know this because in the Ten Commandments we see that we should not murder (Ex. 20:13). Yet, if someone does take the life of another without just cause, life is so important that the only fit and just penalty is to take the life of the murderer (Gen. 9:6). In this case preserving the sanctity of life created in God’s image is more important than the taking of the one life (the life of the murderer) itself.

If this is the case, then surely preserving a human life is far more important than preserving a person’s ability to make the choice they desire. In fact, we also see this simply in the command not to murder. What is being said is that as much as God values choice, he values far more making the right choices, choices which involve trust in and obedience to him (Gen. 2:16-17). And so there are certain choices God forbids because they are wrong, dishonoring to him, and harmful to others. One of those forbidden choices is the taking of a human life without just cause.

Thus, we conclude that to kill a baby in the womb, whom we know to be a human being created in God’s image, is just such a choice God forbids. The choice to abort is not merely a choice about what to do with one’s own body. It is a choice about what to do with someone else’s body.

This leads to the second reason it is not wrong for the government to pass laws that prohibit abortion, which also is the second major matter we take up under this second problem related to abortion.

B. The Sanctity Of Life. 
The Bible is clear that the life of humans, created in God’s image, is sacred. As we saw above, it is not to be taken without just cause (Ex. 20:13) and when it is taken without just cause, the penalty must fit the crime in order to preserve a sense of that sacredness (Gen. 9:6).

To take this one more step, “the Bible teaches that we should think of the unborn child as a person from the moment of conception, and therefore we should give to the unborn child legal protection at least equal to that of others in the society.”[1] Here are three biblical passages as evidence: 
·         In Psalm 51:5, as part of King David’s repentance and confession after his sin with Bathsheba, he writes: “Behold, I was brought forth in iniquity, and in sin did my mother conceive me.” Prior to this statement in the psalm David has been repeatedly addressing his own sin, so he is most likely addressing his own sin in this verse—making the point that his sinful nature goes back even before birth. “This means that he thinks of himself as having been a distinct human being, a distinct person, from the moment of his conception. He was not merely part of his mother’s body….”[2]

·         In Luke 1:35 we read as part of the angel Gabriel’s announcement to Mary that she would be mother of the Messiah: “And the angel answered her, ‘The Holy Spirit will come upon you, and the power of the Most High will overshadow you; therefore the child to be born will be called holy—the Son of God.’” To this we must add that in Lk. 1:43 Elizabeth called Mary “the mother of my Lord.” These verses are significant because they mean that “the incarnation of Christ did not begin when he was a newborn baby, a small child, a teenager, or an adult man. Rather, the divine nature of God the Son was joined to the human nature of Jesus from the moment of his conception in Mary’s womb…. This is [important]…because it means that Christ was a genuine human person long before his birth as a baby on the first Christmas.”[3]

·         In Luke 1:41-44, as part of the account of Mary visiting her relative, Elizabeth (the expecting mother of the forerunner of Jesus: John), we read: “And when Elizabeth heard the greeting of Mary, the baby leaped in her womb. And Elizabeth was filled with the Holy Spirit, and she exclaimed with a loud cry, ‘Blessed are you among women, and blessed is the fruit of your womb! And why is this granted to me that the mother of my Lord should come to me? For behold, when the sound of your greeting came to my ears, the baby in my womb leaped for joy.’” There are two significant points to be made here. To begin, “under the influence of the Holy Spirit, Elizabeth called [her own] unborn child…‘a baby’ (Greek, brephos, ‘baby, infant’). This is the same Greek word that is used for a child after it is born…(Lk. 2:16…18:15; 2 Tim. 3:15).”[4] Additionally, we notice that Mary said the baby in her womb “leaped for joy.” This attributes personal human activity to him…to hear Mary’s voice…[and to] feel joyful about it.”[5]

It is also clear that there is scientific evidence that corroborates the biblical teaching that life begins at conception. Dianne Irving, a biochemist and biologist, as well as an MA and PhD philosopher and professor of the history of philosophy and of medical ethics at Georgetown University, wrote the following, which I will quote at length: 
To begin with, scientifically something very radical occurs between the processes of gametogenesis and fertilization—the change from a simple part of one human being (i.e., a sperm) and a simple part of another human being (i.e. an oocyte—usually referred to as an ‘ovum’ or ‘egg’), which simply possess ‘human life,’ to a new, genetically unique, newly existing, individual, whole living human being (a single-cell embryonic human zygote). That is, upon fertilization, parts of human beings have actually been transformed into something very different from what they were before; they have been changed into a single, whole human being. During the process of fertilization, the sperm and the oocyte cease to exist as such, and a new human being is produced. 
To understand this, it should be remembered that each kind of living organism has a specific number and quality of chromosomes that are characteristic for each member of a species. (The number can vary only slightly if the organism is to survive.) For example, the characteristic number of chromosomes for a member of the human species is 46 (plus or minus, e.g. in human beings with Down’s or Turner’s syndromes). Every somatic (or body) cell in a human being has this characteristic number of chromosomes. Even the early germ cells contain 46 chromosomes; it is only their mature forms—the sex gametes, or sperms and oocytes—which will later contain only 23 chromosomes each. Sperms and oocytes are derived from primitive germ cells in the developing fetus by means of the process known as “gametogenesis.” Because each germ cell normally has 46 chromosomes, the process of “fertilization” cannot take place until the total number of chromosomes in each germ cell is cut in half. This is necessary so that after their fusion at fertilization the characteristic number of chromosomes in a single individual member of the human species (46) can be maintained—otherwise we would end up with a monster of some sort.
To accurately see why a sperm or an oocyte are considered as only possessing human life, and not as living human beings themselves, one needs to look at the basic scientific facts involved in the processes of gametogenesis and of fertilization. It may help to keep in mind that the products of gametogenesis and fertilization are very different. The products of gametogenesis are mature sex gametes with only 23 instead of 46 chromosomes. The product of fertilization is a living human being with 46 chromosomes. Gametogenesis refers to the maturation of germ cells, resulting in gametes. Fertilization refers to the initiation of a new human being.[6]

Conclusion
Chelsea Clinton recently affirmed sentiments shared by many in our society, namely that the legalization of and access to abortion is a matter of reproductive rights and equality for women, and thus advocating for it is a matter of social justice.[7]  Yet, as Christians, we should see that the very opposite is true. Though choice is important and though biblical wisdom would lead us to conclude that a government should not control every choice a person makes, there are some choices it is ethically-right for a government to outlaw. Any taking of life without just cause, such as abortion or euthanasia, is included.[8]

Life originates from God and his design for mankind is to know and enjoy true and full life (which includes both physical and spiritual vitality). As such, part of the call we have to bring righteousness and justice to bear upon the world includes helping each other see that human life, created in the image of God, is sacred and should be protected, whether it is in or out of the womb.[9]

Such is part of the great cause God calls us to live for as we help meet the needs of others, rather than remaining in our comfort zones. May we respond to the call!

Joyfully Seeking Justice With You,

Tom

[1] Wayne Grudem, Christian Ethics: In Introduction to Biblical Moral Reasoning (Wheaton: Crossway, 2018), 571.
[2] Grudem, Ethics, 567-68. 
[3] Grudem, Ethics, 570.
[4] Grudem, Ethics, 567.
[5] Grudem, Ethics, 567.
[6] Dianne N. Irving, “When Do Human Beings Begin?” Catholic Education Resource Center (www.catholiceducation.org), cited in Grudem, Ethics, 571-72.
[7] Al Mohler, in his August 24, 2018 “The Briefing podcast, found at albertmohler.com/the briefing. 
[8] The word “euthanasia” literally means “good death” and refers to allowing persons to end their own life when and how they want. Usually this is advocated when a person is ill and experiencing great pain (which more and more is including pain that is other than a terminal illness). An extreme example of the permission of euthanasia can be found in Belgium, where in 2014, they legalized euthanasia for children. In other words, in a nation where such minors would not be allowed to drive or marry, they can make the decision to end their own life. John Stonestreet writes of this and similar decisions that “autonomy is their god” and “they end up sacrificing their children on its altar.” See John Stonestreet, Roberto Rivera, “When Children ‘Choose’ To Die: Sacrificing Babes On The Altar Of Autonomy,” in the August 21, 2018 podcast, found at breakpoint.org.
[9]There are at least three instances in which God sees the taking of life as just and thus allowable:  In the case of capital punishment, when a person has unjustly and intentionally taken the life of another; in the case of a government who is defending its citizens against lawbreakers from without or within; and in the case of self-defense. See Gen. 9:6; Ex. 22:2-3; Nu. 35:31; Rom. 13:1-7. 

Monday, August 27, 2018

Justice And The Sanctity Of Human Life, Part 1

In this post we begin applying the Bible’s teaching on justice to specific issues that we currently face in our country, issues that advocates of social justice often address.

The first is the issue of human life or the sanctity of human life.

As a reminder, we have defined justice in the following manner: “Justice identifies the moral standard by which God measures human conduct…[his own character as reflected in his moral will]…. Biblical justice, therefore, is the equitable and impartial application of the rule of God’s moral law in society…the understanding and application of God’s moral law within the social realm,”[1] with the understanding that this justice is what is best for all.

If, then, we are to interact with the matter of human life in a way that is just, we must apply God’s moral law as found in his Word to the subject. Yet, to do this in a way that does not by-pass contemporary objections, we must deal with two main problems. We will look at one of them in this post and the second in our next post.

1. Problem One: The Reputation That Christians Are Partisan In Regard To And Unduly Focused Upon Abortion. 
This first problem has to do with the view that many non-Christians have toward Christians, a view that some Christians have come to believe due to its prevalence. It is important to deal with this topic not only because it can tend to stifle a Christian’s voice on the subject, but it also suggests that Christians are unjust on this very topic. We will deal with each part of this problem in turn.

A. Partisanship.
In a May 2012 blog post, “An Open Letter To Young, ‘Post-Partisan’ Evangelicals,”[2] David French,[3] who thought when he was in his twenties he would “fix” the supposedly horrible reputation of older Christians who had gone before him and he would not be so partisan, challenged those today with the same outlook.  French explained that a Christian cannot take a legitimate stand against abortion, for example, without then being thought partisan. After all, with such a stance a person takes a specific side. This is true not just with abortion, but with all the issues we are dealing with in this series. French wrote: 
But I soon realized that my nonpartisanship had a steep price. I could be pro-life, but not too pro-life. You see, if you’re too pro-life; if you talk about it too much, then you can’t be post-partisan. One political party is completely dedicated to legal protection of abortion on demand. The other political party is completely dedicated to repealing Roe v. Wade. If you talk too much about abortion, others will define you, and if you’re defined how can you be independent?

French is correct. One way to avoid being seen as partisan is not to take a stance, especially on issues in which you will be out-of-step with the gate-keepers in our society. This, in fact, is what has happened with many Christians. Because there can be much “heat” in issues like abortion, they conclude that taking a position is being involved in that dirty thing known as “politics” which turns people away from the gospel. So, it is avoided. After all, we want people to like us and see us as loving so that maybe they’ll like Jesus, right?

Hopefully, we now see the problem with this avoidance, especially in light of our last post. Part of the outcome of being united to Jesus Christ and transformed should be living righteously and so pursuing biblical justice. This includes praying for, giving resources in behalf of, advocating for, and voting in such a way that we can uphold the sanctity of human life. We can do it in love, with grace, winsomely, without an unduly partisan spirit, and justly. But do it we must.

B. Undue Focus. 
It is not just partisanship Christians fear, but also the label of being far more focused on culture war issues (such as abortion) than they are on other issues, such as people in poverty. In response to this charge David French wrote the following:[4] 
 As I decisively entered the “culture war” I discovered something shocking: there aren’t that many of us. (What’s that? Are you telling me that Christians aren’t obsessed with gays and abortion? That’s what the polls say!)  As I traveled around the country and spoke at churches, Tea Party rallies, and conferences, I realized that the number of Christians who truly fight the culture war is quite small. How small? In 2011, I researched the budgets of the leading culture war organizations and compared them to the leading Christian anti-poverty organizations.

What did French find? In his post he focused on three Christian relief organizations as compared to pro-family culture war organizations: 
How do these numbers stack up with leading Christian anti-poverty charities? Let’s look at just three:  World Vision, Compassion International, and Samaritan’s Purse. Their total annual gross receipts (again, according to most recently available Form 990s) exceed $2.1 billion. The smallest of the three organizations (Samaritan’s Purse) has larger gross receipts than every major “pro-family” culture war organization in the United States combined. World Vision, the largest, not only takes in more than $1 billion per year, it also has more than 1,400 employees and 43,000 volunteers.

Here is what French concluded:
In other words, Christians are overwhelmingly focused with their money and their time on the poor, not on culture war issues.  Then why are Christians portrayed differently?  Because the media is obsessed with the sexual revolution and demonizes dissent.  If news outlets focus on Christians only when engaged on culture war issues and ignores the much more extensive work we do for the poor in Africa, in Asia, and at home, then it’s no wonder the wider world sees us as politically-obsessed.  Anyone who believes that Christians are in control of their own public image does not understand how public perceptions are created in this country.  No one is in total control of their own image and reputation.  Not even the President — and shame on me for not realizing that in my days of naive rage. (emphasis added)

Throughout the last thirty years that I have been tracking the society and the numbers, evangelical Christians have consistently been much more generous givers of time and resources to help those in need than their liberal counterparts or those who are not Christians. This does not mean that we cannot improve. We very much can!  It does mean that there is a prevalent false narrative about Christians, one which we have started believing ourselves and so to protect our own public image (or so we think), we stay out of the fray. But again, as those redeemed by Jesus Christ, those who love God and love others, how can we not pursue biblical justice in behalf of the babies who are killed in our country and in behalf of the women who are hurt through abortion?

Another form this narrative of undue focus takes is that Christians are focused only upon the unborn children, but not those who are born, nor upon their mothers. When we look at this more closely we find that this too is false.

John Stonestreet, in his July 5, 2018 Breakpoint commentary, wrote the following (and I quote him at length):[5] 
I recently received a critical letter from a Breakpoint listener who resurrected some of these…[old] arguments for abortion. The letter claimed that abortion must remain “safe, legal, and rare,” because there is simply no alternative.
Let me respond: abortion is never “safe.” If it’s successful, someone dies: namely, the child in the womb. And, it frequently leaves the mother with medical and psychological consequences. One study in the British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology found that between 40 and 60 percent of women reported having negative reactions to their abortions, including guilt, nervous disorders, sleep disturbances, and regrets.
And the idea that abortion can be legal and remain rare is also a myth. In many parts of the country, the so-called “right to choose” is used like birth control. In fact, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, just in New York City, one in three babies is aborted. In total, over half a million babies are aborted annually in the United States alone. If we’re talking about the taking of innocent life, how rare is rare?
Another…[old] abortion argument brought up in the letter we received is that financial hardship or the immaturity of the parents justifies the termination of a pregnancy. In other words, a baby born into tough circumstances would be better off dead.
But as my friend Scott Klusendorf points out, if financial hardship or immaturity of the parents are sufficient reasons to kill a child in the womb, wouldn’t they also be sufficient reasons to kill a child ouside of the womb? Nobody thinks parents can dispose of their two-year-old because they can’t afford her!
That’s why the central question when it comes to abortion would be the same one you should ask if your ten-year old son yells from outside “Hey, can I kill this?” Wouldn’t your answer be, “wait, what is ‘this’?”
If the answer is indeed a human, then no circumstance, no matter how tough, justifies that killing.
The most persistent…[old] argument for abortion is that pro-lifers only care about babies when they’re still in the womb—that we preach from our ivory towers but we won’t get our hands dirty taking care of those little lives. Folks, that’s nonsense.
Pro-life pregnancy care centers provide mothers (and fathers) with counseling, training, financial support, baby supplies, and other help. These centers now outnumber abortion clinics at least two-to-one, maybe more.
And Christians are more than twice as likely to adopt as their secular neighbors. According to research published in the Almanac of American Philanthropy, religious Americans are significantly more likely to give to both religious and nonreligious charities than their secular counterparts. And their favorite charities are those that provide basic social services and healthcare.
Look, is there more that we can do? Of course there is. But this idea that pro-lifers don’t care about or seek to help children who are born into tough circumstances—that we won’t put our money or our time where our mouths are—it’s just not true.

Bottom-line, Jesus taught that his true follower will be one who loves others and thus will seek to meet their needs and even save their lives at great cost to themselves, and that is the opposite of walking to the other side of the road, passing by, and ignoring them (Luke 10:25-37). Pursuing biblical justice would include standing for life, for the unborn baby, for the born baby, for the mom, and against abortion.

In our next post we will turn to the second major problem we face in the issue of abortion.

Joyfully Pursuing Justice With You,

Tom

[1] All but the bracketed clause and the last clause of this definition is taken from Tony Evans, Oneness Embraced: Reconciliation, The Kingdom, And How We Are Stronger Together (Chicago: Moody, 2011), 260.
[2] Accessed at patheos.com/blogs/frenchrevolution/2012/05/23/an-open-letter-to-young-post-partisan-evangelicals, on July 10, 2018. 
[3] French is an American attorney (J.D. from Harvard), journalist, and a senior fellow at the National Review Institute. He is a veteran of the Iraq War and a major in the United States Army Reserve. He is a past president of the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education. He is also a staff writer for National Review. Information taken from Wikipedia.
[4] “Post-Partisan Evangelicals.”
[5] “Zombie Abortion Arguments” (accessed at www.breakpoint.org/2018/07/breakpoint-zombie-abortion arguments/).